Baiting Hollow Homes for Sale

Welcome to Baiting Hollow, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This charming hamlet, located along the picturesque North Fork of Long Island, offers a unique blend of tranquility and vibrant community life. Known for its stunning waterfront views, lush vineyards, and rich history, Baiting Hollow is the perfect destination for those seeking a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of city living.

Baiting Hollow boasts a rich tapestry of outdoor activities, with easy access to pristine beaches, scenic parks, and nature trails. Whether you’re an avid hiker or a beach enthusiast, the natural beauty of this area is sure to captivate you. The local community is warm and welcoming, with a variety of seasonal events and farmers' markets that celebrate the region’s agricultural heritage.

For those looking to make Baiting Hollow their home, a wonderful selection of homes for sale awaits. From charming cottages to luxurious waterfront properties, the real estate offerings in this idyllic hamlet cater to a range of preferences and budgets. Each home is infused with the character and charm that define this unique area, providing a perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories.

With its blend of scenic beauty, community spirit, and diverse housing options, Baiting Hollow is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle choice. Discover your dream home in this enchanting hamlet and embrace all that Baiting Hollow has to offer!

Newest Baiting Hollow Homes for Sale

$375,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1045674 MLS

NESTLED ON LONG ISLANDS NORTH SHORE BLUFF~ THIS LITTLE SLICE OF HEAVEN OFFERS THE TRANQUIL SOUND OF THE WATER WASHING ASHORE, UNOBSTRUCTED BREATHTAKING WATER-VIEWS AND BEACH VIEWS, This home was renovated in 2014 and additional Renovations done including Windows, & Sliders Added in 2023 to Accentuate THE WATERVIEWS. NEW ROOF, Updated Eat In kitchen W/White Cabinetry, Granite Counters, Subway Tile Back Splash, Updated Bathroom accented with Shiplap, Engineered Wide plank White Oak Floors, Vaulted Rustic Beamed Ceilings for the authentic cottage feel, Mini Split for Heat & air, Double SLIDERS to New entertainers Deck Also w/Wide Plank Boards, Stackable washer/Dryer, New Stove, New White Storage Cabinetry, 2 Sofas, & Captains Bed with Storage, Exterior Painted 2021 in a Soothing Blue Tone, Interior Freshly Painted 2024, Additional Tiered Deck Off Side for Sunbathing, Rose Bushes & Perennial Plantings offer charm & make it feel like home. Furnished & Ready to Use. Only 1 Hour & 15 Minutes to NYC. Jitney Bus is only 8 Minute Drive from Community. Community is Seasonal open April 15-October 15. Land is Leased at approximately $12,896 annually. Short term rentals Prohibited. Was two separate bedrooms but currently walls down and set up as Open Concept. Could be put back up., Additional information: Appearance:Mint

58 Hillcrest Drive, Baiting Hollow

$714,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1044389 MLS

Spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offering approximately 2,265 square feet of living space on a generous half-acre lot. A bright, welcoming floor plan offers abundant natural light and plenty of room to gather and entertain. The main level features a formal dining room, spacious living room with fireplace, large kitchen with an abundance of cabinetry and storage, convenient half bath, and direct access to the attached two-car garage. Upstairs are three well-proportioned bedrooms with a full hall bath, along with a spacious primary bedroom featuring a private en-suite bath. A large unfinished basement provides excellent additional storage and possibilities for future use. Outside, enjoy a large, open backyard with plenty of space for entertaining and recreation. Set in a quiet residential neighborhood with convenient access to Riverhead and the North Fork's popular vineyards, farm stands, restaurants and local attractions. Property is being sold as-is.

63 Nicholas Way, Baiting Hollow

$159,990

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1042120 MLS

Ever Dreamed of Owning a Vacation Home on Long Island? Now you can. This Charming Well Maintained Cottage offers Numerous Recent Updates Including Updated Electric, Plumbing, Washer & Dryer in New Cedar Enclosure, Custom Cedar Outdoor Shower With Sleek Black Stone Accents & Fixtures, New Retaining Walls, Parking for 2-3 Vehicles, Ample Outdoor Entertaining Area on your Covered Porch. Inside You will find Clean White Cabinetry, & an Open & Airy Living Space along with Two Bedrooms & a Full Bath w/Shower Stall. Private Beach access is just around the corner. Just an hour & 15 minutes from the NYC & With no shortage of Local Activities you will not be disappointed in with this Location. Located inside Desirable Seasonal Beachfront Community of Woodcliff park open April 15 -October 15. Cash Sales Only. Land is leased and not included in sale. Local attractions include: Beach, Golfing, Horseback Riding, Farm Stands, Wineries, Splash Splash Water Park, Aquarium, Outlet Shopping, & More!

15 Cottage Road, Baiting Hollow

$869,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1037778 MLS

Turnkey North Fork living just moments from the Long Island Sound. This beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bath home offers 2,378 sq. ft. of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring an open kitchen with quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances, hardwood floors, a fireplace, and a spacious primary suite. Set on nearly a third of an acre with a two-car garage and access to Edwards Beach, the home is ideally positioned to enjoy the best of Baiting Hollow—just minutes from North Fork wineries, farm stands, dining, and local attractions. Move right in and enjoy the North Fork lifestyle year-round or as the perfect weekend retreat.

1871 Edwards Avenue, Baiting Hollow

$795,999

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1037404 MLS

Welcome home.This charming, tranquil home set on approximately 1.05 acres in desirable Baiting Hollow. Offering 3 bedrooms, two full bathrooms. This property combines comfortable living with the privacy and space of a generous lot. Full finished basement with private office and tons of storage. This is a must see home. The home's practical layout provides flexibility for everyday living, entertaining, or working from home. Outside, the expansive grounds offer plenty of room for recreation, gardening, and creating your ideal outdoor retreat. Conveniently situated near the North Fork's beaches, vineyards, farms, golf courses, shopping, and dining, this home presents an excellent opportunity to enjoy the relaxed East End lifestyle.

71 Triangle Lane, Baiting Hollow

$239,990

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1037498 MLS

Imagine trading everyday stress for lazy summer mornings in a completely renovated three-bedroom cottage that brings genuine Hamptons flair to the North Shore. This turnkey charmer proves that vacation living doesn't have to be complicated. Every inch has been thoughtfully reimagined. Wide plank wood-like laminate floors flow beneath recessed lighting, all controlled by dimmers and motorized shades for the perfect ambiance. White cedar impression siding and Anderson black windows deliver crisp curb appeal, while insulated walls and a mini split keep things comfortable in any weather. The kitchen shines with quartz counters and a five-burner gas stove, and the oversize shower dazzles with shiplap-accented walls and sleek black fixtures. New plumbing throughout means worry-free stays. Best of all, it arrives fully furnished with quality pieces, so you can simply unpack and relax. Outside Enjoy a brand-new front sitting area anchored by a fire pit, plus an outdoor shower for rinsing off after beach adventures. A pebble driveway, electric vehicle charger, washer, dryer, and a handy basement round out the practical perks. Set in a coveted beachfront seasonal community open April fifteenth through October fifteenth, this spot puts vineyards, farm stands, outlet shopping, Splish Splash Water Park, the Long Island Aquarium, and horseback riding all within easy reach. Please note: land is leased and this is a cash-only purchase. Whether you crave a snowbird escape or a summer getaway, seize this rare opportunity and schedule your private tour today. Land lease is $8,335.34 for 2026...

25 Cottage Road, Baiting Hollow

$274,990

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1037418 MLS

Come Vacation On Long Islands North Shore of Baiting Hollow in Desirable Seasonal Beachfront Community of Woodcliff Park open April 15-October 15. Land Lease is approx $9,737.77/2026. Breathtaking Waterviews Exude from numerous locations throughout this home. living Room Accented with Wood ceiling panels charm this home, oversized slider to screened in deck with FULL UNOBSTRUCTED VIEWS, The Kitchen has white cabinetry, You will enjoy doing dishes for the first time as you stare out at the water from your picture window purposely positioned above the sink, Primary & guest bedroom are nice size and both have closets, The second bathroom is just 6 Years Young & offers a Jetted Tub that is also nestled below another picture window, Laundry, Attic storage Flagstone outdoor patio area add to this homes features. Street has only handful of homes on it so it is more private than other locations in park. ONLY home with View on market!! Numerous Local Attractions:Splish Splash water park, Golfing, Farm Stands, Atlantis Aquarium, Beaches, Horseback Riding, Outlet Shopping, & Wine Country. Land is leased and Not included in sale. Cottage comes furnished. Cash Only Sales, Additional information: Appearance:Mint

10 Acorn Path, Baiting Hollow

$1,075,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1010933 MLS

Located within Baiting Hollow Estates on Long Island's North Fork, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 3-bath Colonial offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and coastal living. Set on 1.11 private acres with a wooded backyard, this inviting home features a spacious layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. A grand foyer welcomes you into the home, where you'll find a formal dining room, a first-floor office or potential fourth bedroom, and a spacious family room with a gas fireplace. The updated eat-in kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing stainless steel appliances, a large center island, updated cabinetry, backsplash, and skylights that fill the space with natural light. Additional skylights can also be found in the living area and guest bath. The second level features a generous primary suite with a tray ceiling, walk-in closet, and large en-suite bath, along with two additional bedrooms and full bath. Wood floors run throughout the home, complemented by plantation shutters in the bedrooms and office. Additional amenities include a large laundry room, central vacuum, central air conditioning, two-zone heating and cooling, oil heat with a new burner and water heater, situated on a corner lot with tons of privacy and beautifully landscaped, a full unfinished walk-out basement, and an oversized two-plus-car garage with pull-down attic access. Outdoor living is equally impressive with an oversized rear deck, wraparound front porch, charming gazebo, in-ground sprinklers, and plenty of room to enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Baiting Hollow Estates is comprised of 15 homes that share a gated and maintained staircase to 150 feet of a private beach. HOA dues are just $750 per year and include beach access, gate and lock maintenance, and upkeep of the community landscape circles. Close proximity to the North Fork, Hamptons, golf, boating, vineyards, and so much more.

216 Landing Lane, Baiting Hollow

$2,250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 977813 MLS

Introducing 35 Club Drive at The Estates at Baiting Hollow, a beautifully appointed residence offering 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and thoughtfully designed spaces that elevate everyday living. A gracious floor plan unfolds with refined finishes, highlighted by a striking fireplace that serves as the heart of the home, an elegant butler's pantry ideal for seamless entertaining, and versatile bonus rooms that can be tailored to your lifestyle. The expansive outdoors offer plenty of room for a pool for relaxation and leisure activities. Designed with both sophistication and comfort in mind, this exceptional home provides the perfect balance of luxury, functionality, and timeless style within one of the North Fork's most desirable new communities. The Estates at Baiting Hollow is more than a collection of homes- it is a thoughtfully planned luxury community designed to embrace the North Fork lifestyle. Overlooking the renowned Baiting Hollow Club, residents enjoy sweeping golf course, farmland, and sunset views in a private and picturesque setting. The community blends sophisticated design, smart-home technology, and energy-efficient construction with proximity to the North Fork’s celebrated wineries, beaches, boating, farm-to-table restaurants, and local attractions.

35 Club Drive, Baiting Hollow

$855,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1008371 MLS

Your search is over! Welcome to this stunning home in desirable **Baiting Hollow**, set on a beautifully professionally landscaped **0.94-acre** in a quiet cul-de-sac. Enjoy a bright, open-concept layout designed for effortless everyday living. The chef’s kitchen is a standout, with **Corian countertops**, double ovens, a **dedicated wine cooler**, and a spacious pantry—ideal for cooking and entertaining. Modern conveniences also include a **central vacuum system** with an automatic sweep-in dustpan. Upstairs, the private **primary suite** offers a relaxing en-suite bath, along with **three generously sized bedrooms**. Downstairs, the **full basement** provides endless possibilities for recreation, storage, or extra living space, and includes an **electric transfer switch** for easy generator hookup. Step outside to your own outdoor retreat: a magnificent **Mahogany deck** with a **custom gazebo** (electric and ceiling fan included). The **fully fenced yard** showcases custom **paver walkways**, enchanting **inground lighting**, and a **13-zone sprinkler system**, with plenty of room for a future pool. Additional features include a **2-car garage** with a utility sink and pull-down attic storage. Close to world-class wineries, farms, pristine beaches, shopping, and golf—don’t miss your chance to own this exceptional gem!

77 N Woods Road, Baiting Hollow

$1,050,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 992997 MLS

Elevated and Very Private Home on a Quiet, Cul-de-Sac Street Located 2 Mins from the Beach! Amazing Sunsets from All Rooms Including Expansive 92-Foot Private Deck. The Main Level Features Spacious LR & FDR w/Impressive Wall of Windows, Sliding Andersen Doors to 92 Ft Deck & Hot Tub, Beautiful Vaulted Ceilings, and Anchored by a Dramatic Stone Fireplace. Modern Eat-in Chefs Kitchen with a Large Granite Island. Spacious 3 Bedrooms, Den /Office, 2 Full Baths (& Jacuzzi). Spacious Walk Out Level Basement with Very High Ceilings & Windows, Laundry, & Access to 2 Car Garage & Long Private Driveway. Many Upgrades Include Radiant Heated Floors, Central Vac & Central Air Conditioning. Best Location, Fantastic Vineyards, Splish Splash, Farms, Boating, Golf, and the Best of the North Fork and Hamptons Lifestyle!

10 Silver Beech Lane, Baiting Hollow

$1,495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 977769 MLS

Introducing The Estates at Baiting Hollow-an exclusive community of luxury residences set within a private enclave overlooking the renowned Baiting Hollow Country Club. Perfectly situated at the gateway to the North Fork, this exceptional community offers effortless access to the region’s celebrated farms, vineyards, beaches, and major routes to New York City. As the area’s first thoughtfully designed sustainable development, The Estates at Baiting Hollow integrates advanced smart home systems and cutting-edge energy-efficient technologies, with the potential to achieve Net Zero energy consumption. Set on approximately .58 acres, 25 Club Drive enjoys sweeping golf course and pastoral farmland views. The property allows for a generous rear yard, offering the opportunity to create a custom outdoor retreat, including an in-ground pool or additional amenities. The Fairway Model presents refined one-level living with a modern farmhouse aesthetic. The open-concept great room serves as a central gathering space, soaring 10-foot ceilings. The chef’s kitchen is beautifully appointed with high-end appliances, large center island, custom millwork, quartz countertops, and a walk-in pantry with prep space. Designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living, the dining area opens to a spacious mahogany-covered porch-ideal for both relaxed and alfresco entertaining. The primary suite is a private sanctuary, complete with a generous walk-in closet and a spa-inspired bathroom featuring dual vanities, a soaking tub, separate shower, water closet, and heated floors. Two additional bedrooms are thoughtfully positioned on the opposite wing, complemented by a full bath and a conveniently located powder room. A well-designed laundry and mudroom with custom built-ins provides direct access to the garage for everyday ease. With a focus on sustainability and innovation, available features include solar panels, all-electric systems, high-performance building materials, EV charging capability, battery backup ready, and stormwater management. Additional upgrade options allow for further customization. This distinctive offering blends modern luxury with natural beauty, creating a lifestyle defined by tranquility, convenience, and year-round enjoyment. The complete offering terms for the association are in a CPS-7 Application available from the Sponsor. HO22-0002.

25 Club Drive, Baiting Hollow

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.