Middle Island Real Estate

Welcome to Middle Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This charming community offers a unique blend of suburban serenity and convenient access to urban amenities, making it an ideal place to call home.

Middle Island is surrounded by the natural beauty of Long Island, with lush parks and scenic landscapes that invite outdoor enthusiasts to explore. The nearby Rocky Point and Wildwood State Parks provide ample opportunities for hiking, picnicking, and enjoying the great outdoors. With its picturesque surroundings, Middle Island is perfect for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

The community is known for its friendly atmosphere and strong sense of belonging. Residents enjoy a peaceful lifestyle, with local shops, restaurants, and services just a stone's throw away. The area is served by the Longwood Central School District, which is highly regarded for its commitment to educational excellence.

For those who crave a bit more excitement, Middle Island is conveniently located near major roadways, allowing for easy access to the vibrant towns of Patchogue, Port Jefferson, and the stunning beaches of the South Shore. Whether you’re looking to enjoy a day at the beach, indulge in fine dining, or partake in seasonal festivals, Middle Island places you right in the middle of it all.

With its welcoming community, beautiful landscapes, and convenient location, Middle Island is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Discover the charm of Middle Island and see why so many are proud to call this delightful town home!

Newest Listings in Middle Island

$720,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1032641 MLS

Welcome to your private retreat in Middle Island. Nestled on nearly four-tenths of an acre with serene lake access, this beautifully renovated ranch blends modern finishes with effortless single-level living. The heart of the home is an impressive kitchen featuring quartz countertops, a large center island, custom cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances that flows seamlessly into spacious living and dining areas perfect for entertaining. Five spacious bedrooms provide room for everyone, while the inviting fireplace, oversized deck, and picturesque backyard create the perfect setting for relaxing or hosting gatherings. Every detail has been thoughtfully updated, allowing you to move right in and enjoy the lifestyle this exceptional property offers.

7 Lake Drive, Middle Island

$1,235,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1030942 MLS

Welcome to 42 E Bartlett Road, a rare real estate opportunity in Middle Island, NY, combining two side-by-side parcels for a total of 11.20 acres of flat, tree-lined land. This unique package includes a 1.38-acre residential lot with the main home, connected to an expansive, private 9.82-acre lot. Surrounded by mature trees, the property offers excellent privacy and a spacious, park-like setting, giving you a quiet country feel while keeping you close to everyday amenities. The home is a classic, single-story ranch with 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, including a primary bedroom with an ensuite bath, all designed entirely on one level for easy daily living. Featuring two cozy fireplaces and an open layout, the house serves as a great blank canvas for your own updates, renovations, or future additions, and already boasts major recent upgrades including a new roof, new windows, a new oil burner, and a new septic system installed within the last two years. Properties with this much acreage are hard to find, and the large, level ground offers many possibilities, whether you want to set up agricultural or equestrian spaces, build a larger private compound, or look into future land subdivision. Located in the Longwood Central School District, this property provides a great balance of peace and convenience, with easy access to local parks, shopping, dining, and major roads.

42 E Bartlett Road, Middle Island

$549,999

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1032130 MLS

Set on a sprawling 1-acre lot in a quiet, peaceful location, this spacious 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home offers the space and flexibility today's buyers are looking for. Zoned for horses, the property provides wide-open outdoor space that's increasingly hard to find so close to everyday conveniences perfect for equestrian buyers or anyone who wants room to breathe, garden, or simply enjoy the privacy of a full acre. The floor plan offers excellent flexibility for multi-generational living, with a layout well-suited to a mother-daughter setup with two electric meters. Five generously sized bedrooms provide comfortable space for a large household or guests. Quiet and private, yet still convenient to local roads, schools, and amenities this is a rare combination of acreage, flexibility, and location.

8 Swezey Lane, Middle Island

$679,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1031128 MLS

Set on approximately .43 acre with a private wooded backdrop adjoining DEC land, this spacious four-bedroom Colonial offers a flexible layout, generous room sizes and numerous updates. The home features an updated eat-in kitchen with propane cooking and newer appliances, hardwood and tile flooring, and two exceptionally large bedroom options. Additional highlights include a full unfinished basement with laundry, utility sink and pellet stove, a two-car attached garage, a spacious driveway and patio, pull-down attic, 200 amp electric and wall AC units. Recent improvements include the roof, siding, windows, garage doors. Enjoy a peaceful setting with ample outdoor space and a shed for additional storage.

10 Turnpike Boulevard, Middle Island

$599,990

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1030369 MLS

Welcome to a rare opportunity to own a sprawling ranch, that has 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths with garage and basement on an acre. It is the only one on long island of its kind, that is financeable under 600k. Located in middle island horse country location, backing a huge preserve with deer trails coming off the lot. Supreme privacy, on a culdesac street. Originally a cottage, that was expanded by the owner, who has maintained this home for the past 45 years. All additions are legal with CO's and owner has all paperwork if needed. Starting from the outside you will find a bold deep blue siding with perfection shingles in the front. The roof is an arch shingle that is fairly new along with all newer windows and doors. Large rocking chair porch allows you to enjoy the breeze you will get from living in horse country. Below the additions you will find a covered patio area that is currently used for storage but can also have many diversified uses. There are two long driveways that can be helpful for camper and boat storage. Interior has an entry parlor, with a classic feel to it. The kitchen has solid wood cabinets and then all upgraded appliances/island/and bullnosed granite throughout. the living room has a propane gas fireplace as well. The bedrooms are the new age split plan so the primary and its own bath separate from secondary bedrooms and their own bath. Flooring is either laminate or engineered wood with tile in baths. there is a large basement with both interior and exterior access and is walk in through the front. hw heater and furnace have recently been replaced along with a 200 amp service. All in all this is a very well cared for home with all reasonable rooms sizes.

5 Cedar Grove Terrace, Middle Island

$649,990

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1030258 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home, built in 2017 and thoughtfully designed for today’s lifestyle. Featuring an inviting open-concept floor plan, soaring 9-foot ceilings, central air conditioning, beautifully updated floors, and updated bathrooms. This home offers the perfect blend of style and comfort. The spacious primary suite is a private retreat, complete with a large walk-in closet and a beautifully appointed bath. The full basement provides exceptional additional living space and offers excellent extended potential with the proper permits. Step outside to your own backyard oasis! Enjoy summers by the freeform inground swimming pool, entertain guests in the pool house, or relax under the gazebo overlooking the expansive paver patio. The fully fenced, professionally landscaped yard offers privacy and plenty of room for outdoor gatherings. Situated on a quiet dead-end street, this move-in-ready home combines modern construction, exceptional outdoor living, and endless possibilities. Conveniently located near local amenities, this is a rare opportunity you won’t want to miss!

22 Deer Avenue, Middle Island

$355,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1027778 MLS

Rarely Available East-Facing Unit with Premium Fountain Views & Resort Amenities! Welcome home to one of the coolest and most desirable second-floor units in the entire complex. Bathed in beautiful morning light, this east-facing 2-bedroom, 2-full-bathroom residence features a private balcony overlooking serene views of the community fountain—the perfect spot for your morning coffee. Step inside to a completely refreshed, turnkey interior boasting gorgeous hardwood flooring, new lighting, and stylish new window treatments throughout. The heart of the home is the stunning, brand-new kitchen, fully equipped with sleek new appliances and modern finishes. Both full bathrooms have been beautifully renewed with a contemporary design. Upgraded stairs with custom carpet stair treads lead you to the spacious bedrooms, which feature plush new carpeting underfoot. For ultimate convenience, the unit includes a dedicated laundry area. Living here feels like a year-round vacation. The highly desirable community offers a robust amenity package, including a massive swimming pool, a fully equipped fitness gym, a vibrant recreation room, and a grand clubhouse perfect for hosting events. With every detail meticulously updated from top to bottom, there is nothing left to do but move right in and enjoy luxury, low-maintenance living. Schedule your showing today before this premier unit is gone! Location. Quiet. Second floor. Nice and cool. Updated!

159 Fairview Circle Unit #291U, Middle Island

$409,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1025089 MLS

Move right into this beautifully maintained townhouse in the Coventry Manor community of Middle Island. Offering the perfect blend of comfort and style, this spacious home features an open and inviting floor plan with soaring cathedral ceilings that fill the living room with natural light. The dining area flows seamlessly into the kitchen, which features granite countertops, creating an ideal space for everyday living and entertaining. This home offers three generously sized bedrooms, including a convenient first-floor bedroom, one full bathroom and one half bathroom, central air conditioning, abundant storage, an attached one-car garage, and a private driveway. Step outside to your own private patio, perfect for relaxing or enjoying outdoor dining. Coventry Manor offers outstanding resort-style amenities including a clubhouse, in-ground swimming pool, tennis courts, basketball court, playground, beautifully maintained common grounds, snow removal, water, trash collection, and professionally landscaped grounds, providing a carefree lifestyle. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, parks, and major roadways including the Long Island Expressway and William Floyd Parkway, this home offers both convenience and tranquility. Don't miss this opportunity!

10 Amesworth Court, Middle Island

$275,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1025350 MLS

Wake up to breathtaking views of Artist Lake from this beautifully maintained second-floor 2-bedroom residence! Filled with natural light, this inviting home features a spacious living room with a large picture window that creates a bright and airy atmosphere, while the adjoining dining area offers two generous storage closets for added convenience. The updated galley kitchen is equipped with stainless steel appliances, including a gas stove and dishwasher, making meal preparation both stylish and functional. The oversized primary bedroom is a peaceful retreat, offering abundant natural light and two large mirrored-door closets for exceptional storage. The second bedroom opens directly onto a private deck overlooking picturesque Artist Lake—the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, unwind after a long day, or simply take in the tranquil waterfront scenery. Additional features include a brand-new HVAC system for year-round comfort and in home laundry room. Residents of The Shores enjoy outstanding community amenities, including a sparkling outdoor inground swimming pool and a welcoming clubhouse. Ideally located near shopping, restaurants, and major highways, this home combines comfort, convenience, and scenic beauty in one exceptional package. Don't miss this opportunity to enjoy lakeview living at its finest!

244 Lake Pointe Circle Unit ##244, Middle Island

$199,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1023449 MLS

Why rent when you can own ??? Fully renovated and spacious, this upper-end 1-bedroom unit boasts a brand-new kitchen with modern appliances, an oversized living room, and a large dining area. The large primary bedroom offers a generous walk-in closet and a fresh new bath. Bright and inviting, the home features a beautiful deck overlooking a park-like setting—perfect for grilling or simply relaxing. Enjoy a lifestyle of easy living - HOA fee includes exterior maintenance and landscaping, snow removal, water, sewer, gas, and taxes. Hidden Meadows is conveniently located for an easy commute to the LIE. It is near shopping and restaurants, and a short distance from the East End beaches, vineyards, and Farm stands.

58 Bailey Court Unit #58, Middle Island

$469,999

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1023820 MLS

Desirable Malibu model in the highly sought-after, guard-gated Birchwood at Spring Lake community. This sun-filled 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath condo offers soaring ceilings, elegant moldings, and an open floor plan designed for easy living and entertaining. The main level features an eat-in kitchen, a spacious family room with sliders to a private patio, and an open living and dining area ideal for gatherings. Upstairs, the primary suite offers two walk-in closets and a brand-new bathroom featuring a private vanity nook and walk-in shower. Two additional bedrooms share another newly updated full bath, and a pull-down attic provides additional storage. Recent updates include new windows, a heating system, and central air conditioning, along with a new refrigerator and dishwasher, offering peace of mind and added value. Enjoy resort-style living with amenities that include a 9-hole golf course, indoor and outdoor pools, a fitness center, clubhouse, tennis, pickleball, racquetball, bocce, basketball courts, a billiards room, library, walking and biking trails, playgrounds, and beautifully landscaped grounds. Community services include exterior and grounds maintenance, pool upkeep, sewer, snow removal, trash, and water.

824 Birchwood Park Drive, Middle Island

$535,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1006900 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully updated, well-maintained end-unit townhouse in the highly sought-after gated community of Birchwood at Spring Lake. Offering 2 bedrooms plus a possible 3rd bedroom and 2 full bathrooms, this spacious home features a desirable first-floor primary bedroom, an updated full bath, a laundry room, and direct access to the attached garage. The bright and airy living room boasts soaring ceilings and flows seamlessly into the dining area and open-concept kitchen, complete with sliders leading to a private paver patio. Designed for entertaining, the outdoor space features a gazebo, a new awning, a fire pit, and plenty of room to relax, entertain, and enjoy. The second level offers a generously sized bedroom, a spacious den that can easily serve as a home office or possible 3rd bedroom, a full bathroom, and an extended attic space converted into an oversized walk-in closet. Recent updates include the roof, central air conditioning, hot water heater, washer and dryer, refrigerator, kitchen slider, carpeting on the stairs, vinyl fencing, and LED lighting. Residents of Birchwood at Spring Lake enjoy resort-style amenities, including a 9-hole executive golf course, two clubhouses, four pools (two indoor and two outdoor), tennis courts, pickleball, bocce, racquetball, ping-pong, and a wide variety of social activities. Exceptional living in one of Long Island's premier gated communities!

1 Robert Lane, Middle Island

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.