Middle Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Middle Island, New York—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County. Known for its serene landscapes and a strong sense of community, Middle Island offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and convenient access to urban amenities. With its tree-lined streets and charming residential neighborhoods, this quaint town is ideal for families, retirees, and anyone looking for a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Middle Island boasts a rich history, with its origins dating back to the 17th century. Today, it is home to a variety of recreational opportunities, including parks, nature trails, and nearby beaches, making it a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. The town’s commitment to preserving its natural beauty is evident in the abundance of green spaces, providing residents with ample opportunities for hiking, biking, and enjoying the great outdoors.

When it comes to real estate, Middle Island has a diverse selection of homes for sale that cater to various lifestyles and budgets. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to modern townhouses, there’s something for everyone in this welcoming community. Many properties feature updated amenities and are situated within proximity to local schools, shopping centers, and dining options, ensuring that convenience is never far away.

If you’re looking to invest in a home that offers both comfort and community, Middle Island is the perfect choice. Explore the available listings today and take the first step towards making this enchanting town your new home!

Newest Middle Island Homes for Sale

$739,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1047975 MLS

Welcome to this well-maintained High Ranch offering 4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, with a versatile layout ideal for multi-generational living or potential rental income with the proper permits. The lower level features a spacious family room, one bedroom, a full bathroom, laundry area, and ample storage. A private entrance provides convenient access, adding flexibility to the home’s living arrangements. Upstairs, the main level welcomes you with a bright and inviting living room featuring vaulted ceilings, a cozy fireplace, and beautiful hardwood floors. The kitchen offers wood cabinetry and a convenient peninsula with seating, while the adjoining dining areas provide the perfect space for gatherings and entertaining. This level also includes three additional bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The spacious primary bedroom features vaulted ceilings, 2 walk-in closets, and a private en-suite bathroom. Step outside to the generously sized 1 acre property, designed for both relaxation and recreation. Enjoy a private patio, basketball court, and plenty of room for summer fun and outdoor entertaining. Additional highlights include a two-car garage, hot tub and ample storage. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this charming and versatile house your new home!

1 Chen Court, Middle Island

$649,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1045796 MLS

This beautiful and spacious 3 bedroom 2 bath ranch sits on a huge flat shy acre. The huge eat in kitchen is the heart of this home and overlooks the pristine sunny rear yard with access to a paved patio. Every room in this beauty exudes warmth. The ample living room with cozy fireplace says "welcome home". Primary bedroom has a walk in closet, and a full bath that features a soaking tub and separate shower. A quiet sitting room off the kitchen, a full bath and 2 more bedrooms, a separate laundry room and pantry complete the main floor. A full finished basement offers huge options for home work space, playroom, gym or just extra space to roam or set up hobbies. With a 1 car garage, attic space and 2 sheds this house has plenty of storage too! Central A/C, Oil Heat. Longwood SD

39 Creekside Drive, Middle Island

$674,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1045437 MLS

This beautiful home offers Approx. 2,400 square feet of living space on a shy half-acre. This spacious home features four bedrooms, two full baths, and a partial basement. The primary bedroom is conveniently located on the main level with its own bath. Enjoy an open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, recessed lighting, and a wood-burning fireplace in the great room. The updated kitchen features granite countertops and newer appliances. Additional highlights include carpet and laminate flooring, an extension added in 1998, updated windows and siding, 7 Year Young Roof and a boiler with a separate hot-water storage tank and four heating zones. The TimberTech front porch and PVC fencing were updated in 2021. Completing the property is an oversized two-car garage measuring 24' x 24'. Spacious, inviting, and ready to welcome you home—this is the one you’ve been waiting for!

57 Wellington Road, Middle Island

$959,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1044677 MLS

Welcome to 7 Sander Court, a completely remodeled Hampton-style luxury home with high-end finishes, custom millwork, and magnificent white oak hardwood floors throughout. This sophisticated 3/4-bedroom, 4-bath residence offers a perfect combination of elegance, comfort, and contemporary design for today’s modern lifestyle. A spacious and inviting mahogany-wrapped front porch welcomes you into the grand entry foyer. Interior highlights include a dramatic stone floor-to-ceiling gas fireplace, a large living room, and a formal dining room. The gourmet kitchen is equipped w/ custom-built tall cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and an Oversized waterfall-style center island. The kitchen opens to a large and tranquil backyard, creating an ideal setting for everyday living and entertaining. The primary suite boasts a gorgeous custom-built walk-in closet and a spa-like bathroom with an oversized dual shower. The fully fenced and professionally landscaped home features an expansive paved-stone patio, a large deck, and a large greenhouse. Additional amenities include a beautifully finished basement with an outside entrance and an attached 2.5-car garage. Conveniently located near schools, excellent shopping, restaurants, parks, beaches, and Long Island’s renowned wineries. A truly distinctive, move-in-ready home offering refined finishes, generous living space, and exceptional indoor-outdoor living.

7 Sander Court, Middle Island

$599,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1043192 MLS

Enjoy Country Club Living! Welcome to Birchwood at Spring Lake, a premier, gated golf community offering resort-style living in the heart of Middle Island. This beautifully updated and spacious Fairfax Model 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom Home features: Tile And Wood Flooring, Oak Kitchen, , Newer Washer Dryer, New Primary Bath, , Fresh Paint And New Roof. This Home has a Spacious attic with plenty of storage space. Enjoy the privacy of the outdoor patio. This Home is set within an exceptional country club community situated on a private 9-hole golf course (fee included in the HOA), residents enjoy access to two clubhouses, four pools, tennis courts, pickleball, Bocce, racquetball, two fitness centers, beautifully maintained grounds with walking paths, a social and event calendar, and an active social lifestyle with amenities designed for every interest. This is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle.! Enjoy maintenance-free living with every comfort and convenience at your fingertips – all within a vibrant, resort-like community. Professional Photos To Follow.

619 Spring Lake Drive, Middle Island

$549,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1041400 MLS

Welcome to this custom-built ranch situated on a large, wide, and level lot with Solar panels that help to provide very low electric bills! Many custom/upgrade features, include: 2012 Updated kitchen w/ Quartz & Corian counters; Ductless A/C system-Jan 2026; Vinyl siding 2024; Roof 2013; new gutters w/ leaf filters; Andersen Replacement windows; Hardwood flooring; Stove 12/2025; Refrigerator 2022; Dishwasher 2021; New garage door; Commercial Garage door opener; heated basement; cedar closet; Quality Hot water heater; Hunter ceiling fans; PLUS a CHOICE 12-month Home Warranty is included with this purchase! Take a VIRTUAL TOUR by clicking the following link: https://my.matterport.com/show/?m=f22gdVQ1tJ5 See it today and call it home tomorrow!

31 Cedar Branch Street, Middle Island

$600,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1037203 MLS

Location, location! Welcome to Birchwood at Spring Lake, a premier gated community offering resort style living in the heart of Middle Island. This gorgeous and well maintained 2 bedroom, 2 full bath home is right on the golf course and is one of the most sought after free standing ranches in this community! Once inside this spotless home you will find an open and airy floor plan with Pergo flooring throughout! You will love to start the day having morning coffee in this warm and inviting eat in kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and an abundance of wood cabinets! The dining room with crown molding, a sleek built in credenza and a knee wall flows seamlessly into the huge living room with vaulted ceilings, perfect for entertaining! Past the living room is a large den which adds even more living space. The den has sliding glass doors to a large patio, a retractable awning and unbelievable views of the golf course. A separate hallway on the other side of the home leads to the 2nd bedroom, a full bathroom with a tub and a large primary bedroom with closets galore and its own primary bathroom with ceramic tile floors and a beautiful custom walk in shower. A spacious laundry room with washer and dryer and a 1 car garage complete this home providing everything you need to live in comfort! Newer updates include heating/cooling system, hot water heater, pergo floors, retractable awning, dishwasher/microwave, custom shower in primary bathroom, 2 back fences and blacktop driveway! This home has central air conditioning and inground sprinklers. Residents of Birchwood at Spring Lake can enjoy so many amenities including 2 indoor pools, 2 outdoor pools, 2 modern clubhouses each with their own gyms and playgrounds, a 9 hole golf course, tennis courts, pickle ball courts, basketball and racquetball. There are numerous clubs and events throughout the year and beautifully maintained grounds with walking paths, 24 hour security and so much more! Trash removal, snow removal, water, lawn maintenance included in HOA fees. Move in ready!! This home will not last! Make it yours today.

63 Madison Circle, Middle Island

$525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1038914 MLS

Welcome to Middle Island! This charming ranch is nestled right in the hart of middle island and offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and convenience. Situated on just shy of an acre of land and directly across from the park, this home provides a peaceful setting with plenty of outdoor space. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a garage, and a full basement, there is plenty of room to make this home your own. A wonderful opportunity for anyone looking for a spacious property in a charming neighborhood with park views and room to enjoy and grow!

617 Granny Road, Middle Island

$500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1038189 MLS

Welcome to 24 Oakcrest Avenue! This beautiful, move-in-ready Ranch offers 3 bedrooms, 1 updated full bathroom and a comfortable single-level layout featuring hardwood floors throughout. The full unfinished basement with outside entrance provides excellent additional storage and plenty of future possibilities. Outside, enjoy a huge backyard with a manicured lawn, large storage shed and plenty of space for entertaining, gardening or relaxing. A spacious private driveway provides parking for multiple vehicles. Extremely low taxes of under $8,000 before STAR make this an incredible opportunity and a perfect path to homeownership. Located within the Longwood School District and conveniently situated near Middle Country Road, shopping, restaurants, parks, recreation and the Long Island Expressway for easy travel throughout Long Island. Enjoy everything Middle Island has to offer, including nearby Artist Lake, Cathedral Pines County Park and The Pines Nature Preserve. Whether you’re purchasing your first home, downsizing or simply looking for a move-in-ready Ranch with a spacious property and low taxes, this home checks all the boxes. What are you waiting for? Your dream home awaits!

24 Oakcrest Avenue, Middle Island

$508,800

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1034885 MLS

Colonial-style residence offering approximately 2,484 square feet of living space with 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 1 half bathroom situated on an approximately 22,216-square-foot lot. This two-story home features a traditional floor plan with spacious living areas designed for everyday living and entertaining. Additional features include an attached two-car garage, covered porch, public water and sewer service, and natural gas hot-water baseboard heating. The property's generous lot provides outdoor space for recreation, landscaping, and enjoyment of the surrounding residential setting. Located within a residential section of Middle Island, the property offers convenient access to shopping, dining, schools, parks, transportation routes, and other everyday services. The surrounding area is characterized primarily by one- and two-family homes in a stable suburban market.

14 Cedar Grove Terrace, Middle Island

$599,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1033309 MLS

This high visibility location features a converted residence currently being used as office space for a church. Zoned A Residential, this acre plus parcel could potentially be rezoned to J commercial.

645 Middle Country Road, Middle Island

$720,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1032641 MLS

Welcome to your private retreat in Middle Island. Nestled on nearly four-tenths of an acre with serene lake access, this beautifully renovated ranch blends modern finishes with effortless single-level living. The heart of the home is an impressive kitchen featuring quartz countertops, a large center island, custom cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances that flows seamlessly into spacious living and dining areas perfect for entertaining. Five spacious bedrooms provide room for everyone, while the inviting fireplace, oversized deck, and picturesque backyard create the perfect setting for relaxing or hosting gatherings. Every detail has been thoughtfully updated, allowing you to move right in and enjoy the lifestyle this exceptional property offers.

7 Lake Drive, Middle Island

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.