Mt. Sinai Homes with Private Lot features

Welcome to Mt. Sinai, New York—a charming gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County. This picturesque hamlet, located on the North Shore of Long Island, offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With its serene landscapes, friendly community, and proximity to stunning beaches, Mt. Sinai is an ideal place to call home.

One of the standout features of Mt. Sinai is its diverse range of homes, particularly those with private lot options. Imagine waking up each morning to the tranquility of your own spacious backyard, perfect for entertaining friends, gardening, or simply enjoying a peaceful retreat. Homes with private lots in this area provide not just a residence but a lifestyle—offering the space and privacy that many homeowners desire.

Families will appreciate the top-rated schools, recreational parks, and local amenities that Mt. Sinai has to offer. The community is known for its welcoming atmosphere, making it easy to forge lasting friendships. Additionally, the nearby scenic coastline provides endless opportunities for outdoor activities, from beach days to hiking trails.

Whether you’re seeking a cozy cottage or a sprawling estate, Mt. Sinai’s real estate market boasts a variety of options tailored to meet your needs. With the perfect blend of nature, community, and convenience, homes with private lots in Mt. Sinai promise not just a place to live, but a place to thrive. Explore the possibilities and discover your dream home in this enchanting locale!

Newest Mt. Sinai Homes with Private Lot features

$919,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1027854 MLS

Tucked away at the end of a long private driveway on a beautifully manicured acre, this custom farmhouse-inspired colonial offers timeless charm with today's most sought-after finishes. A welcoming wraparound front porch sets the tone before stepping inside to rich hardwood floors, custom millwork, oversized Andersen windows, and beautifully designed living spaces that blend warmth with sophistication. The heart of the home is an absolutely stunning chef's kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel Samsung appliances, quality cabinetry, and an effortless flow into the main living areas—perfect for everyday living and entertaining alike. Upstairs you'll find four spacious bedrooms, including an exceptional primary suite with triple closets and a beautifully renovated spa-inspired bath featuring dual vanities and an oversized dual rain shower. Every bathroom has been thoughtfully updated with timeless finishes. One of the home's most unforgettable features is the hidden bookcase passage leading to the unfinished third-floor attic—a rare space with unlimited potential. The unfinished lower level offers approximately 8 foot ceilings, outside entry, and endless possibilities for recreation, fitness, hobbies, or future expansion. Outside, enjoy nearly an acre of level property with a patio, underground sprinklers, intentional landscaping, and plenty of room to relax or entertain. Additional highlights include a NEW Biasi boiler and Riello burner, 2-zone central air, central vacuum, oversized garage, newer 50-year roof and gutters, and countless custom details throughout. All mechanical systems are young creating a completely move-in ready home. Located within the Mount Sinai School District, this is a home that combines privacy, craftsmanship, and everyday comfort in one exceptional package.

93 Chestnut Street, Mt. Sinai

$1,300,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1025468 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 5 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Colonial nestled on over 3 private acres, offering the perfect combination of classic charm, modern comfort, and exceptional space. The main level features a sun-filled living room with a fireplace, a warm and inviting den with a second fireplace, a formal dining room for entertaining, and a spacious eat-in kitchen designed for everyday living. A first-floor bedroom, private home office, and convenient half bath provide added flexibility for guests, remote work, or multigenerational living. Upstairs, the generous primary suite offers a walk-in closet and private full bath, while three additional bedrooms and another full bath provide plenty of space for family and guests. The fully finished basement adds even more versatility with a kitchenette, dining area, family room, and laundry area, making it ideal for extended living, recreation, or entertaining. Step outside to your own private backyard oasis featuring a fully fenced in-ground pool, an elegant stone patio, and expansive open grounds perfect for outdoor entertaining, recreation, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Complete with ample parking and a desirable blend of privacy and convenience to local amenities, this exceptional property offers the space, comfort, and lifestyle you've been searching for.

77 Shore Road, Mt. Sinai

$1,199,997

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1001121 MLS

Welcome to this exceptional Center Hall Colonial located in the prestigious Woodhull Manor section of Mount Sinai. Immaculately maintained and beautifully appointed, this impressive 6-bedroom home offers the perfect combination of elegance, comfort, and resort-style living. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious main level is highlighted by custom crown molding throughout, custom blinds, and stunning built-in cabinetry surrounding the fireplace in the family room, creating a warm and sophisticated gathering space. The primary en-suite serves as a private retreat featuring two walk-in closets, a full bath, and an additional nursery/dressing room, offering incredible flexibility and luxury. Generously sized secondary bedrooms provide ample space and flexibility for use. The fully finished basement with egress window adds even more living space, perfect for a media room, gym, playroom, home office, or guest accommodations. Offering 3,526 sq ft of beautifully designed living space, plus a 772 sq ft basement - totaling 4,298 sq ft, this home provides plenty of room for everyone. Step outside and experience your own private backyard oasis. Professionally landscaped grounds surround the picturesque built-in pool. Surround sound audio with exterior speakers create the ultimate setting for entertaining or relaxing in total serenity. The backyard also features a stone fire pit, wood play-set, Ninja Course, dog run, and in-ground sprinklers for added convenience. Perfectly situated on a dead-end courtyard, off a dead-end street, this home offers exceptional privacy while still being close to local amenities. Enjoy nearby parks, beach club access, and scenic walking trails that make this location truly special. A rare opportunity to own a meticulously cared-for home in one of Mount Sinai’s most sought-after neighborhoods.

4 Crabapple Court, Mt. Sinai

$599,999

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 973163 MLS

New Price! Move Right Into This Beautifully Renovated 3 Bedroom Ranch Set On A Generous 0.35 Acre Property In The Mount Sinai School District. The Home Features An Updated Eat-In Kitchen, Andersen Windows, And A Bright, Comfortable Layout Designed For Easy One Level Living. A Partial Basement And Stand Up Attic With Existing Framing Provide Valuable Storage And Exciting Possibilities For Future Use. Outside, Enjoy A Spacious Fenced Backyard And An Oversized Driveway With Plenty Of Parking. Conveniently Located Near Shopping, Dining, And North Shore Beaches. Low Taxes, A Desirable Location, And Room To Grow.

56 Wylde Road, Mt. Sinai

$8,780,000

831946 MLS

This well-known North Shore Long Island Landmark Plant Nursery & Garden Center with Residential Property is now For Sale! You can now seize this rare opportunity to purchase a developed and highly profitable 7.5 picturesque acres of Agricultural/Residential property in the heart of historic Mount Sinai! Servicing the community for over 25 years, with a following of loyal customers, this turnkey business is a beloved community staple, boasting extraordinary visibility, accessibility, and consistent retail/wholesale foot traffic. This meticulously maintained property operates year-round, producing over 10,000+ plants annually, including Leyland Cypress, Hollies, Green Giant Arborvitae, ornamental plants, privacy and screening plants, perennial and annual flowers. Stunning display gardens feature massive natural rock walls, outdoor lighting, open pavilions, venues and infrastructure capable of hosting large outdoor events. 600 ft of parking lot frontage on the highly visible North Country road, capable of 50+ parking spaces and perfect for equipment, vehicles, and seasonal operation such pumpkin picking, produce stands, Christmas tree displays and more. Additionally, the country inspired estate at 191 N. Country Rd Mt. Sinai, a charming 2,200 SF Four-Bedroom cedar shake Farmhouse on fully fenced and fastidiously maintained and private landscape is included in the offering. Oversized Storage Barn & Gift Shop – Endless retail and inventory possibilities. A four-lot subdivision both agriculture and residential with endless possibilities for expansion and development, equestrian, winery and hospitality. Zoned A1 200-68-3-6.2 3.75 Acre Taxes: $13,444.39 200-68-3-6.5 .90 Acre Taxes: $6,302.09 200-68-3-6.6 1.41 Acre Taxes: $2,688.89 Zoned Residential 191 N. Country Rd 200-68-3.5 Built 1940 4BR/2.5Bth 2400 s/f Taxes: $10,906.36 An incredible opportunity for horticulture professionals, entrepreneurs, developers and investors looking to step into a profitable, well-established operation with great infrastructure and room for expansion.

185-191 N Country Road, Mt. Sinai

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.