Bay Shore Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bay Shore, a hidden gem nestled on the picturesque south shore of Long Island, New York. This charming neighborhood in Suffolk County is renowned for its vibrant community spirit, stunning waterfront views, and rich history. With its close-knit atmosphere and a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, Bay Shore has become a sought-after destination for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

As you stroll through Bay Shore, you’ll discover a delightful array of local shops, boutiques, and eateries that reflect the area’s diverse culture. The iconic Bay Shore Marina offers a gateway to the Great South Bay, making it a haven for boating enthusiasts and those who enjoy leisurely waterfront strolls. The community is also home to beautiful parks, such as the expansive Gardiner County Park, where residents can enjoy picnics, trails, and recreational activities.

For those looking to make Bay Shore their home, the real estate market offers an enticing selection of homes for sale. From charming single-family houses with classic architecture to modern condos with stunning bay views, there’s something for everyone. With a variety of price points and styles, potential buyers can find their ideal sanctuary in this thriving community.

Bay Shore’s excellent schools, convenient access to public transportation, and proximity to major highways make it an ideal location for commuting to New York City while still enjoying the serenity of suburban life. Come and explore Bay Shore, where community, convenience, and coastal charm await you!

Newest Bay Shore Homes for Sale

$665,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1029207 MLS

Beautifully Updated Open-Floor-Plan Ranch-RECENTLY RENOVATED TO INCLUDE NEW KITCHEN, NEW BATH, AND NEW FLOORING Discover this stunningly refreshed ranch home offering four spacious bedrooms and two beautifully appointed full bathrooms. Step inside to a bright, open-concept layout featuring a brand-new gourmet kitchen with sleek modern finishes, thoughtfully renovated bathrooms, and elegant gleaming hardwood floors throughout the hallways. The home boasts a fully finished basement with its own private outside entrance—ideal for extended household, guests, or a versatile in-law suite. Outside, enjoy a large, private yard perfect for relaxation and entertaining, highlighted by an expansive deck that invites unforgettable gatherings. This move-in-ready gem combines comfort, flexibility, and room to grow—all in a warm, welcoming package that must be seen to be fully appreciated.

182 New York Avenue, Bay Shore

$650,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1029205 MLS

Beautifully Renovated Ranch | 3 Bed | 2 Bath | Finished Basement With outside entrance| Private Dead-End Location Step into this cozy yet spacious 2-3 bedroom ranch home, beautifully renovated and full of charm. Nestled among nature trees and vibrant flowers, the home features premium new flooring, a modern kitchen, and a stylish bathroom. Enjoy the comfort of gas heat and a huge finished basement perfect for additional living space, guests, or recreation. Outside, you’ll love the huge backyard and ample outdoor space on a sizeable lot — ideal for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying nature. This home sits as the last house on a quiet dead-end street, offering exceptional privacy and tranquility. With an inviting outside entrance and thoughtful updates throughout, it perfectly blends comfort and convenience. This rare gem won’t last long and is ready for a quick closing.

3 Hickory Place, Bay Shore

$729,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1028145 MLS

Welcome to this charming Cape Cod. Step outside to your own private backyard with a basketball court, above ground pool, covered patio and plenty of room for entertaining.

27 W Lakeland Street, Bay Shore

$749,999

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1020844 MLS

Welcome to your gorgeous colonial home that’s been awaiting you!! Nicely located within 10 minutes from shopping, dining, the Bay Shore Marina, and central to all LI's major highways. This beauty sits on 0.37 acres, boasts a Cul de sac driveway and falls nothing short of spectacular. The first floor hosts beautiful gray water-proof laminate hardwood floors throughout while having an open concept design with the spacious living room, a renovated kitchen that has endless soft close cabinetry which rests on breathtaking granite countertops, a large custom pantry, stackable W/D & a doggy haven near the front door for the fur baby lovers. The dining room, fully renovated bathroom with standup shower & 1 of the 5 bedrooms are also on the first floor along with a brand new Tankless Combo gas heat & hot water system. The second floor has a brand new bathroom that has a bath tub, a vanity with double sinks, bluetooth enabled surround sound, 4 spacious bedrooms that can easily fit queen size beds in it while the primary bedroom can have a California King bed to match its large walk in closet. Last but certainly not least, the backyard is a true hostess dream!!! Right off the sliding doors from the kitchen, The magnificent backyard has a full outdoor kitchen with a hibachi grill, bbq grill, ample counter space, mini fridge and high bar seating that can be used while watching T.V The outdoor living space is covered by 2 gazebos. You also have the option to take a swim in the beautiful` large above ground pool or the hottub- the possibilities to spend time with loved ones & friends under the stars is truly endless! This home will not last-run to make your showing appointment with me today! House is being sold as-is & 90% of outdoor oasis is included in the sale.

1634 N Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.