Huntington Bay Homes for Sale

Welcome to Huntington Bay, a picturesque gem nestled on the North Shore of Long Island, New York. This charming village, part of Suffolk County, is renowned for its stunning waterfront views, tranquil atmosphere, and a close-knit community that feels like home. With its lush landscapes and serene surroundings, Huntington Bay offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and suburban comfort.

The neighborhood is characterized by its stunning historic homes, many of which boast breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound. The architecture here is as diverse as its residents, featuring everything from classic colonial designs to modern coastal retreats. The real estate market in Huntington Bay is vibrant, with a variety of homes for sale that cater to different tastes and lifestyles. Whether you're seeking a cozy cottage or an expansive waterfront estate, you'll find options that suit your needs.

Huntington Bay is not just about beautiful homes; it also offers an array of recreational activities. Residents enjoy access to pristine beaches, scenic parks, and charming local shops and restaurants. The nearby Huntington Village is a cultural hub, featuring art galleries, theaters, and a lively dining scene that makes it easy to enjoy a night out.

For families, Huntington Bay is served by top-rated schools and a plethora of community events that foster a strong sense of belonging. With its idyllic setting and welcoming atmosphere, Huntington Bay is more than just a place to live—it's a lifestyle. Explore the homes for sale in this enchanting neighborhood and discover the perfect place to call your own.

Newest Huntington Bay Homes for Sale

$2,350,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1030239 MLS

Nestled on over two private acres in the prestigious Village of Huntington Bay, this impeccably renovated Center Hall Colonial is a masterful blend of timeless architecture and modern luxury. From the gracious foyer, elegant formal living spaces unfold, including a sophisticated dining room and an inviting living room centered around a classic fireplace—ideal for both intimate gatherings and grand-scale entertaining. Rich hardwood floors, exquisite moldings, custom millwork, and refined architectural details are showcased throughout, while the thoughtfully designed floor plan features a chef's kitchen with premium appliances, a sun-filled four-season room, a handsome library, and beautifully appointed gathering spaces. Upstairs, the luxurious primary suite offers a spa-inspired bath and dressing room, while the resort-style backyard boasts a gunite pool, charming pool house, and beautifully landscaped outdoor entertaining areas. Completing this exceptional offering is access to the exclusive Nathan Hale Beach Association, where a private beach, floating dock, cabana, and vibrant waterfront lifestyle embody the very best of North Shore living.

2 Kaiser Hill Road, Huntington Bay

$1,525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1030906 MLS

Set in the heart of Bay Hills, this is a home you will not find anywhere else. It was originally designed by Hoffman Grayson Architects as the architect's own residence, and it shows in every detail. Soaring ceilings, custom millwork and decorative columns give the rooms a sense of scale and craftsmanship that still feels current today. The home has been beautifully updated throughout. The kitchen was renovated with custom cabinetry and granite counters. Two baths were taken down to the studs in 2024, including a spa quality primary bath with radiant heated floors, heated backlit mirrors, dual sinks and custom storage. The floor plan is versatile. The first floor den easily works as a fourth bedroom or guest suite, with a newly renovated full bath nearby. Additional improvements include Andersen High Performance windows, new 200 amp electrical service with a generator transfer switch, a new roof, and central air with a new condenser. There is a fireplace in the den, laundry on the main floor, and a tandem garage. Outside you will find peeks of water and the easy pace of beach life. Membership in the Bay Hills Beach Association (fee) includes a private beach with lifeguard, mooring rights, kayak racks and barbecues, along with tennis, pickleball and basketball courts and a full calendar of community events. The home sits in the Incorporated Village of Huntington Bay, which has its own police department. Huntington Village, with its restaurants, shops, theater and harbor, is just minutes away. Architect designed, meticulously maintained and truly one of a kind.

12 Valley Drive, Huntington Bay

$1,700,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1019906 MLS

Set in the Incorporated Village of Huntington Bay, this is a home built for bringing people together. A Belgian-block circular drive sweeps past layered gardens to a crisp double brick facade, and inside, freshly painted rooms and gleaming hardwood floors give the home a bright, welcoming feel. The living areas were made for entertaining. A vaulted ceiling, clerestory windows and a wall of glass fill the rooms with sun, while an oversized fireplace with a hand-carved mantel and a built-in bar make hosting effortless. The dining room, richly detailed with hand-carved paneling from the Astor Estate, opens to a veranda overlooking the property. The kitchen with wood cabinetry and granite counters opens to a private brick-walled patio, a welcoming spot for morning coffee or evening drinks with friends. Designed for adaptable living, the floor plan features flexible bedroom suites with en suites and lounge areas. A lower-level retreat and an all-season solarium provide ultimate versatility. Outside, the spacious grounds unfold like a private park, with mature maples, seasonal blooms, and walled patios that invite guests to spread out and settle in. At its heart, a wonderful heated in-ground pool and spa are wrapped by a generous deck, with a hand-painted poolside mural by noted Long Island artist Hans Gabali adding a touch you will not find anywhere else. Even the 2-car garage is heated and air conditioned. The community offers the added privacy of private roads and its own police. Minutes to Huntington's beaches, town and marinas, and within an hour of Manhattan, this is a warm, gracious home for a buyer who loves to entertain and live close to the water.

39 Upper Drive, Huntington Bay

$1,175,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1017465 MLS

Welcome to 10 Rancher Place, a fabulous farm ranch set on beautiful property in the heart of Huntington. This inviting five bedroom, three bath home offers a warm and flexible layout with generous living space, comfortable bedrooms, and wonderful natural light throughout. Designed for easy everyday living and entertaining, the home blends classic character with the space today’s buyers are looking for. Set on beautiful private property, the outdoor setting is a true highlight, offering plenty of room to relax, entertain, garden, or simply enjoy the privacy and tranquility of the surroundings. Ideally located near Huntington Village, shops, restaurants, parks, beaches, and transportation, 10 Rancher Place presents a special opportunity to enjoy charm, space, and convenience in one of Huntington’s most desirable areas.

10 Rancher Place, Huntington

$2,599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 919790 MLS

Traditionally elegant brick, 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath center hall Georgian colonial located in the much sought after enclave of Wincoma in Huntington Bay with winter waterviews of Huntington Harbor. This charming home is beautifully set on a flat half acre of landscaped property with close proximity to the private Wincoma beach and a short distance to the association dock. The gracious foyer with its sweeping staircase provides the loveliest preview of the character and style that abounds throughout this very special residence! Entry hall features two closets, tiled flooring, convenient half bath and access to the living room and dining room on either side. The sunken formal living room, perfect for entertaining, is light and bright with a large bay window. The formal dining room is generously sized to accommodate all your guests. The fabulously outfitted chef’s kitchen is updated with Woodmode cabinetry, granite countertops and high-end appliances including; Wolf gas stovetop, Subzero fridge, Dacor oven and Bosch dishwasher. Peninsula seating, a dining area, tile flooring with radiant heat, warming drawer, ice maker and wine fridge are additional attractive and functional features. Sliders in the kitchen provide access to the private backyard. Next to the kitchen, the large mudroom offers amazing custom built-in storage organizer and entry to the two-car garage, along with an updated full bathroom with shower stall. Off the kitchen, an inviting den area with custom built-in cabinetry, detailed millwork and French doors that open to the brick patio. This space also features an additional sunken living area anchored by a wood burning fireplace and a second set of interior French doors leading to the living room. Upstairs; four spacious bedrooms all with ample closet space. The well-appointed primary suite offers a double closet, a large custom walk-in closet and updated full bath with double sink vanity, jetted tub and steam shower. Three additional bedrooms equipped with custom closet systems and a hall full bathroom offers tub shower and double sink vanity complete the second floor. The full basement provides wonderful additional space with endless possibilities and offers a separate laundry room, storage and utilities. A picture perfect private fenced yard and brick patio awaits for al fresco relaxation and entertaining. Wincoma private beach just down the street is yours to enjoy year-round - swim, play and participate in association social events on the waterfront! Additional features of this home include; 10 zone in ground sprinklers, updated Andersen windows, 2 zone central air conditioning, 3 zone heat, high efficiency oil burner, indoor/outdoor speaker system, separate hot water heater, automatic turn on gas generator, updated cesspool, 150 amp electric, updated roof and gutters, updated fencing, driveway and stacked stonework. Wonderful opportunity to live in the Incorporated Village of Huntington Bay, which includes a town hall and separate police department, in addition to being a few miles away from Huntington Village and the Long Island Railroad. Welcome home!

336 Bay Avenue, Huntington Bay

$1,999,999

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 842578 MLS

Set Within The Sought-After Wincoma Association, This Exceptional 100 Year Old Expansive Home Offers Just Shy 5000 Square Feet Of Living Space. Timeless Architectural Details And Old World Charm. This Property Is Situated On Level .64 Acre With Mature Plantings, Brick Patio, Walkways And Rocking Chair Front Porch With Peeks Of Waterview. Elegant Formal Living Room With Wood Burning Fireplace, Formal Dining Room With Large Windows Providing Abundant Sunlight. Inviting Sky-Lit Kitchen With High End Appliances, Tiled Floor And Cozy Fireplace. Library/Family Room With Beautiful Parquet Flooring, Vaulted Ceiling, Custom Built-In Shelving And Cabinetry With French Doors Leading To A Brick Patio. Billiards/Game Room Also Featuring Custom Parquet Floors, Wet Bar and French Doors to Patio. Kingsize Primary Bedroom With A Gas Fireplace And Juliet Balcony And Waterview. The Main House Offers Four Additional Bedrooms And Four Full Baths Plus A Powder Room. The Multi-Level Layout Offers Flexibility Across Three Levels Providing Ample Space For a Variety Of Uses Including Guest Accommodations, Work-From-Home Or A Multi-Generational Home. Large Detached Two Car Garage With A Finished Studio And Full Bath Adds Exceptional Versatility And Potential For A Wide Range Of Uses. Enjoy Access To Wincoma Association Amenities, Including Private Beach, Dock, Mooring Rights, And Playground, Offering A Unique Coastal Setting.

3 Wincoma Drive, Huntington Bay

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.