Mattituck-Cutchogue Homes with Farmhouse Style

Welcome to the picturesque community of Mattituck-Cutchogue, nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. Known for its charming landscapes and rich agricultural heritage, this area offers a unique blend of rural tranquility and modern conveniences. The Mattituck-Cutchogue School District stands out as one of the region’s highlights, providing an exceptional educational experience for families. With a commitment to academic excellence, the district boasts small class sizes, dedicated teachers, and a range of extracurricular activities that nurture well-rounded students.

As you explore the real estate opportunities in this enchanting locale, you’ll discover a treasure trove of farmhouse-style homes that radiate warmth and character. These residences often feature classic architectural elements such as wide porches, exposed beams, and spacious layouts that invite gatherings and create a sense of community. Imagine sipping your morning coffee on a sun-drenched porch, surrounded by sprawling gardens and the gentle sounds of nature.

Living in Mattituck-Cutchogue means more than just a home; it’s a lifestyle enriched by local vineyards, charming shops, and access to stunning beaches. The area’s strong sense of community is reflected in its local events and farmer’s markets, where you can enjoy the fruits of the land and connect with your neighbors.

If you’re seeking a place where quality education meets the idyllic charm of farmhouse living, look no further than Mattituck-Cutchogue. Here, you’ll not only find a house but a true home in a community that celebrates the beauty of life on Long Island.

Newest Mattituck-Cutchogue Homes with Farmhouse Style

$1,100,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1041698 MLS

Full of character, this historic farmhouse pairs the warmth of an older home with the comfort and functionality of a comprehensive renovation. The four-bedroom, three-bath residence has a welcoming, easygoing feel, with a layout that works equally well for everyday living and entertaining. A gracious wrap-around porch sets the tone, offering an inviting setting at all hours. Inside, sun-filled living spaces feature hardwood floors, a beautifully appointed kitchen with a large island, and a cozy living room. A first-floor bedroom and full bath provide added flexibility. Upstairs, the primary suite includes a private bath, while two additional bedrooms share a third full bath. Ideally situated moments from Mattituck Inlet and Love Lane's shops, restaurants, and amenities, the property offers charm, authenticity, and the ease of modern living.

185 Maiden Lane, Mattituck

$1,150,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1033686 MLS

A Rare North Fork Farmhouse with a Heated Barn and Endless Possibilities Tucked away on three-quarters of an acre in a quiet Mattituck neighborhood, this beautifully updated North Fork farmhouse offers the perfect blend of timeless charm, modern updates, and exceptional versatility. Surrounded by a peaceful setting, the property provides plenty of room to relax, entertain, and enjoy the North Fork lifestyle, with thoughtfully designed indoor and outdoor spaces that make you feel right at home. Designed for comfortable living and effortless entertaining, the home features four bedrooms and four full bathrooms across three finished levels. The thoughtfully renovated interior showcases hardwood floors, custom millwork, a beautifully appointed quartz kitchen with shaker cabinetry, and a wood-burning fireplace that anchors the inviting living and dining areas. All four bathrooms feature radiant heated floors, providing comfort and warmth throughout the year. A first-floor bedroom and full bath provide flexibility for guests or single-level living, while the finished lower level—with an additional bedroom, full bath, and spacious family room—offers exceptional space for recreation, a home office, or extended stays. Upstairs, the primary suite features a generous walk-in closet and beautifully appointed bath, while the second upstairs bedroom also enjoys its own walk-in closet. A standing-seam metal roof, approximately five years old, adds lasting value and peace of mind. Step outside to enjoy a freshly painted rear deck overlooking a newly fenced backyard designed for outdoor living, complete with mature landscaping, a tranquil koi pond, hot tub, dedicated fenced garden area, charming playhouse, and abundant space for a future swimming pool. A truly exceptional feature is the property's heated nearly 1,000-square-foot galvanized steel barn with convenient secondary access from Main Road. Equipped with electricity, oversized doors, soaring ceilings, a durable 12-inch concrete floor, and a wood-burning stove, this remarkable space offers endless possibilities as an artist's studio, workshop, garage, collector's showcase, or substantial storage for boats, vehicles, equipment, and hobbies. Few North Fork properties combine an updated farmhouse with a heated barn of this size and versatility. Paired with its peaceful setting just minutes from Love Lane, the grocery store, beaches, wineries, and farm stands, this is a property that offers exceptional flexibility for the way people live today.

365 Rachels Road, Mattituck

$649,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1024859 MLS

This 4-bedroom, three-level home sits in the heart of Cutchogue — one of the North Fork's most coveted addresses. Offered strictly AS IS, WHERE IS, with no representations or warranties, this is a drive-by opportunity for the visionary, the investor, or the end-user ready to make their mark on a property with real bones. The appeal is clear: a two-car detached garage, solid frame construction, and the kind of understated presence that fits naturally into the North Fork landscape. Inside, based on the footprint and layout you have hardwood floors, an eat-in kitchen, forced-air oil heat, two levels of living space, a basement with Bilco doors, and a partial attic speak to a home with genuine structure and flexibility. And the surroundings? Unmatched. McCall Wine, Pellegrini, Pugliese, Suhru and Lieb Vineyards are practically at the doorstep. Farm stands overflow every season, and the Southold Historical Museum's Maple Lane Campus anchors the neighborhood in history and community. Opportunities like this on the North Fork don't wait. Sold with tenants.

26170 County Road 48, Cutchogue

$2,600,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 994280 MLS

Cutchogue Farmstead. Ideal North Fork location. This property includes the home, a 2600 sf barn with horse stalls, water and electric, outbuildings, and 4.5 acres of vines planted in Merlot, Sauvignon Blanc and Riesling varietals. This 1800's restored farmhouse is set on 17.5 acres of level, fertile land. Development rights are intact offering not only agricultural potential but also subdivision and other options. The farmstead's manageable land size is suitable for an eco-friendly, entry level enterprise and also offers additional acreage to an established owner looking to increase crop production. The 3BR, 2 BA farmhouse has a lovely, covered porch with a Western exposure, great for afternoon get-togethers. A patio with a pergola overlooks the planted vines. Opportunity abounds in this 17.5-acre, development rights intact property in Cutchogue, the sunniest place in New York State. REALLY! Central, accessible North Fork location. Bring your concept to life here.

35950 Main Road, Cutchogue

$1,899,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 986519 MLS

Masterfully built, blending timeless design with modern comforts and expert craftsmanship, creating an undeniable sense of harmony and place, on a lovely 1/2-acre level lot, just moments from Love Lane, Strong's Marina and Bailey Beach 3000 Grand Ave. is the perfect North Fork country house. Clad in classic cedar shingles and anchored by a welcoming front porch, this home immediately feels like the perfect North Fork retreat. Inside, uplifting natural light pours through expansive windows, illuminating an elegant foyer and dining room. The kitchen supports both everyday living and effortless entertaining, featuring Quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, drawer microwave and a generous island. The first floor also includes a lovely private ensuite bedroom. On the second floor we find the primary suite, a serene sanctuary, featuring a spa inspired bath. Two additional guest bedrooms share this level. The exterior is designed for outdoor enjoyment featuring a heated saltwater pool with expansive paver patio. New construction with completion in Fall 2026

3000 Grand Avenue, Mattituck

$4,350,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 976938 MLS

MAGIC ON OREGON ROAD Romance, Elegance and Timeless beauty over 38 acres on bucolic Oregon Road, you couldn't ask for anything more! 36 acres of DRS land which includes 30 planted acres of grape vines, deer fencing and bird netting, irrigation in place for an additional 2-3 acres of planting and a potential wine tasting area. The updated vintage farmhouse rests on 2 acres of DRI land and features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sun drenched open floor plan, eat-in-kitchen, dining area, sitting area with reading nook, living room with a fireplace. Step outside and enjoy lush landscape surrounding the pool, outdoor shower and vineyard views! Surrounded by award winning North Fork wineries, restaurants, farm stands, boating & great shopping.

2600 Oregon Road, Mattituck

$1,495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 932413 MLS

17525 County Rd. 48 (aka Middle Rd). Currently being used as a "tree farm", large farmhouse w/high ceilings, open living/dining area, craft room, den and office space. First floor full bath, full row of storage closets. Second floor offers large primary bedroom with high ceilings & 2 additional bedrooms, full bath. Inground pool, large patio area, huge accessory building with large overhead door, 2.06 acres (150 x 600) with partial irrigation zoned AC Agriculture Conservation (Residential). Endless possibilities with large outbuilding for the hobby enthusiast, country farmer or one looking for a serene lifestyle amongst the beautiful North Fork surroundings.

17525 County Road 48, Cutchogue

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.