Old Brookville Homes with Colonial Style

Welcome to Old Brookville, a picturesque village nestled in the heart of Nassau County, New York. This charming community is renowned for its serene atmosphere, lush landscapes, and a rich tapestry of history that dates back to the early 20th century. With its tree-lined streets and stately homes, Old Brookville offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and proximity to the vibrant cultural and economic opportunities of Long Island and New York City.

One of the most captivating features of Old Brookville is its stunning collection of Colonial-style homes. These timeless residences, characterized by their symmetrical facades, gabled roofs, and classic brick or clapboard exteriors, evoke a sense of elegance and charm. Many of these homes are set on expansive lots, providing ample space for gardens, outdoor activities, and picturesque views of the surrounding nature. The Colonial architecture not only showcases a sense of history but also offers modern amenities that cater to today’s discerning homeowners.

Living in Old Brookville means enjoying a lifestyle that emphasizes both community and privacy. Residents relish the opportunity to unwind in this idyllic setting while being just a short drive away from the bustling energy of nearby towns and cities. With top-rated schools, recreational parks, and a strong sense of community spirit, Old Brookville is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive.

Whether you’re drawn to the classic beauty of Colonial homes or the serene lifestyle that Old Brookville offers, this village is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. Come explore the charm and elegance of Old Brookville, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Old Brookville Homes with Colonial Style

$6,999,000

7 Beds ⋅ 9 Baths ⋅ 1021590 MLS

Old Brookville | Welcome to 3 Valentine Farm Court, where timeless architecture, exceptional craftsmanship, and an unmatched collection of luxury amenities define one of the North Shore's most impressive private estates. Positioned behind double iron gates at the end of a secluded cul-de-sac, this stately brick center hall colonial is situated on more than three meticulously landscaped acres, combining remarkable privacy with an extraordinary level of recreation and entertaining amenities. The residence is introduced by a spectacular two-story domed foyer showcasing a sparkling chandelier, intricate hand-painted ceiling details, and extensive custom millwork carried throughout every level of the home. Formal and informal living spaces are thoughtfully arranged, including an expansive formal living room, richly appointed mahogany library, inviting family room with one of three wood-burning fireplaces, formal dining room, powder room, and a spacious first-floor en-suite bedroom with separate exterior access. The custom kitchen is appointed with premium gas appliances, custom cabinetry, a center island with seating, an adjoining breakfast area, and an expansive butler's pantry connecting directly to the formal dining room. Extending from the main level, an elevated terrace with a built-in outdoor kitchen overlooks the estate grounds and pool complex below. The second level features five bedroom suites, each with their own full bathroom. Occupying its own wing of the home, the primary suite includes a private balcony overlooking the property, separate sitting room, two oversized walk-in closets, and an expansive en-suite bathroom with dual vanities and a jetted soaking tub. Designed as an exceptional recreational and entertaining space, the lower level features a custom wet bar, expansive gathering areas, a fully equipped fitness center, additional bedroom and full bathroom, oversized laundry room, and a below-grade indoor sports court with min. 15-foot ceilings—a rarely available amenity in residential construction. The outdoor amenities are equally impressive. The resort-inspired grounds are centered around an oversized gunite swimming pool with an integrated spa and water features, surrounded by expansive patios and mature landscaping. A fully equipped pool house includes a full bathroom, laundry facilities, and an indoor kitchen with a built-in grill opening directly onto the pool terrace. Completing the estate is a full-size sports court configured for both tennis and basketball, along with an oversized three-car garage equipped with vehicle lifts offering additional space for the car enthusiast. Representing an exceptional combination of scale, craftsmanship, and amenities on more than three private acres, 3 Valentine Farm Court presents a rare opportunity within one of the North Shore's most distinguished settings.

3 Valentine Farm Court, Old Brookville

$2,499,999

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1019434 MLS

This extraordinary Old Brookville estate at 19 Pheasant Hill Lane, featured in Architectural Digest, is a rare Georgian inspired residence that embodies timeless architecture, exceptional craftsmanship, and refined design. Perfectly positioned on two flat, private acres along one of Old Brookville’s most peaceful and coveted streets, this 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath home offers elevated living within the award winning North Shore School District. A charming circular driveway welcomes you to the stately facade, where grand Georgian columns create an unforgettable first impression. Beyond the marble foyer, the home unfolds with elegant living spaces rich in character and architectural detail. Luxurious marble bathrooms, custom designer lighting throughout, and a spectacular all glass cupola that fills the home with natural light showcase the remarkable quality and craftsmanship found in every room. Designed for today's lifestyle, the thoughtfully planned layout includes a first-floor bedroom, ideal for guests, extended family, or a private home office. Every space reflects warmth, sophistication, and timeless appeal, creating a home that is both inviting and impressive. The fully finished lower level is an entertainer's dream unlike any other. Featuring an expansive restaurant style bar, a custom built nightclub inspired entertainment venue complete with a DJ booth, dance floor, and generous gathering areas, this one of a kind space is perfectly suited for hosting unforgettable celebrations and private events. Outside, the sprawling two acre property offers endless possibilities to create your own resort style backyard oasis. With ample room for a luxurious pool, spa, outdoor kitchen, tennis or pickleball court, and beautifully landscaped gardens, the grounds provide the perfect canvas for exceptional outdoor living. Ideally located just minutes from the charming villages, fine dining, boutique shopping, renowned country clubs, parks, and Long Island Rail Road stations, this exceptional residence offers the perfect balance of privacy, convenience, and prestige. A truly remarkable Architectural Digest featured estate where timeless elegance, extraordinary entertaining, and the coveted Old Brookville lifestyle come together in one exceptional offering.

19 Pheasant Hill Lane, Old Brookville

$4,795,999

11 Beds ⋅ 14 Baths ⋅ 1016829 MLS

A truly extraordinary opportunity to create one of Brookville's most distinguished private estates. Nestled on an expansive 15-acre parcel in the prestigious Village of Old Brookville, this remarkable property offers an unparalleled setting on one of the area's most coveted and desirable streets. Plans envision a magnificent 22,000-square-foot luxury residence thoughtfully designed to blend timeless elegance with modern sophistication. Surrounded by mature landscaping and serene natural beauty, the estate offers exceptional privacy while remaining conveniently located near renowned schools, country clubs, fine dining, and major transportation routes. A picturesque private pond serves as the centerpiece of the grounds, creating a tranquil and captivating backdrop for the future residence. The vast acreage presents limitless possibilities for world-class amenities, including formal gardens, resort-style outdoor living spaces, recreational facilities, and equestrian pursuits. Rarely does an offering of this caliber become available—a unique chance to build a legacy estate tailored to your vision in one of Long Island's most exclusive enclaves. An exceptional canvas upon which to create a truly iconic residence

1 Penny Pond Court, Old Brookville

$6,850,000

7 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 991638 MLS

Set behind private gates in the prestigious Estates at Greenfield, this stately brick Georgian Colonial is perfectly positioned on three + magnificently landscaped acres, offering an exceptional blend of timeless architecture and resort-style living. A gracious approach leads to a generous courtyard, creating a striking first impression and a true sense of arrival. Inside, a dramatic two-story center hall marble foyer showcases a sweeping wrought iron circular staircase and exquisite, detailed millwork that sets the tone for the home’s refined interiors. The formal living room is both elegant and inviting, complete with a custom built-in bar and hardwood floors while the generous dining room is perfectly suited for grand entertaining. A warm and inviting den with a fireplace sits just off the chef’s kitchen and sunlit breakfast nook, creating an ideal flow for everyday living. A richly appointed home office features its own fireplace, custom built-in shelving, and a convenient half bath. The first floor is further enhanced by a private ensuite bedroom, perfect for guests or extended family. The second level offers a luxurious primary en-suite retreat with a fireplace, a gracious sitting room, and multiple custom-fitted closets. The spa-like marble bathroom adds to the sense of indulgence. Four additional ensuite bedrooms provide comfort and privacy, while a fabulous bonus room offers flexibility as a second den, media lounge, or computer room. The lower level has been thoughtfully designed for recreation and relaxation, featuring a game room, media area, gym, and abundant storage. Outdoors, the property is truly extraordinary—lush, expansive, and beautifully curated with mature specimen trees that provide both privacy and natural beauty. Designed for both relaxation and recreation, the grounds include a sparkling pool and hot tub, a full-service cabana, and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen ideal for seamless entertaining. A sports court and playground complete this exceptional offering. The property is simply divine—an all-encompassing retreat in The Estates at Greenfield, where every amenity has been thoughtfully curated, offering a lifestyle so complete there is truly no reason to ever leave home.

6 Evergreen Way, Old Brookville

$3,299,888

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 977675 MLS

Welcome to a rare opportunity to own a fully renovated and extended estate—rebuilt from the studs up and reimagined for modern luxury in the heart of one of Long Island’s most coveted neighborhoods. Set on a beautifully manicured 2 acre lot, this 6-bedroom, 5.5-bathroom smart residence combines sophisticated design, premium finishes, and cutting-edge amenities, offering a seamless blend of elegance. Every inch of the home reflects quality and intention—from the radiant heated floors throughout the entire main level and every bathroom to the sleek, designer fixtures and finishes throughout. The gracious first floor features a private guest suite with a separate entrance, ideal for extended family and guests. The chef’s kitchen is the true centerpiece—a culinary dream outfitted with a massive center island, top-tier stainless steel appliances, including a 48” Bertazzoni induction range with double ovens, oversized refrigerator and freezer, dual dishwashers, custom cabinetry, beverage drawers, and thoughtful built-ins—all designed to inspire both intimate dinners and large-scale entertaining. The second floor is home to a luxurious primary suite with a spa-inspired en-suite bath, radiant heated floors, oversized closet, and tranquil views of the property. Three additional spacious bedrooms upstairs offer generous closets, and large windows that flood the rooms with natural light. With a dedicated second-floor laundry area, convenience meets everyday function for busy households. The fully finished basement features its own private exterior entrance and offers an abundance of versatile space, including a wine cellar, gym, recreation, full laundry room, and more— The home's brand-new exterior features include a new roof, striking black energy-efficient windows, and a large Trex deck that opens from the kitchen to your own private oasis complete with an in-ground pool. Every system has been updated—new electrical, plumbing, floors, HVAC, and insulation—ensuring true turnkey luxury living. This is more than a home—it's a statement. A rare offering of timeless craftsmanship and modern design in one of the most distinguished enclaves.

33 High Farms Road, Old Brookville

$5,490,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 845880 MLS

Where Drama Meets Design Welcome to nearly 8,000 square feet of pure fabulous in one of the North Shore’s most prestigious enclaves. This newly reimagined estate has been transformed from top to bottom in the last 24 months, creating a home that is equal parts glamorous, playful, and unforgettable. From the moment you step inside, you’re swept into a world of high style and high impact. The soaring ceilings set the stage, while bold architectural details and designer finishes bring a sense of drama to every room. The custom chef’s kitchen is as functional as it is stunning—perfect for hosting everything from cozy family dinners to glamorous cocktail parties. Every detail was designed to delight. The pink laundry room will make you smile every time you walk in, and the sleek, sophisticated man bar is party-ready for unforgettable nights with friends. Every corner of this home tells a story of creativity, luxury, and fun. Step outside and it only gets better. The grounds are your private resort: a sparkling pool glistening in the sun, a full tennis court for a quick match, and beautifully landscaped gardens that feel like your own private park. Whether you’re entertaining on a grand scale or enjoying quiet evenings under the stars, this property delivers it all.

89 Pound Hollow Road, Old Brookville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.