Setauket Homes with Colonial Style

Welcome to Setauket, a picturesque village nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. Known for its rich history, stunning landscapes, and a vibrant community, Setauket offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and urban accessibility. With its charming tree-lined streets and scenic views of the Long Island Sound, this idyllic locale is perfect for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

Setauket is steeped in history, with roots tracing back to the 17th century. The village is home to several historical landmarks, including the Setauket Mill and the historic Setauket Presbyterian Church, which add to its quaint charm. Residents enjoy a strong sense of community, with local events and farmer’s markets that foster connections among neighbors.

One of the standout features of Setauket is its stunning collection of Colonial-style homes. These timeless residences exude elegance and character, often showcasing classic architectural details such as symmetrical facades, gabled roofs, and spacious porches. The Colonial homes in Setauket provide a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for creating lasting memories with family and friends. Many of these properties boast lush gardens and expansive yards, offering plenty of space for outdoor activities and relaxation.

In addition to its alluring homes, Setauket is conveniently located near top-rated schools, shopping centers, and recreational facilities. With easy access to major roadways and public transportation, commuting to nearby cities is a breeze.

If you’re looking for a charming community with a rich history and beautiful Colonial homes, Setauket is the perfect place to call home. Discover the magic of this enchanting village and embrace a lifestyle filled with warmth, history, and endless possibilities!

Newest Setauket Homes with Colonial Style

$949,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1041938 MLS

Also offered for lease at $5200/mo. The very best of North Shore living - just up the block from your private Village beach on Port Jefferson Harbor, with lounging areas and mooring rights - introducing 18 Walnut, in the idyllic, harborside community that is the Incorporated Village of Poquott. Warmth abound, this home has elements of craftsman, bungalow, and saltbox design, inside and out, with genuine curb appeal and a footprint spanning approximately 2,250 sq ft that stands apart from the cookie-cutter norm - a coastal charmer with upgrades already in place and room to make it your own. Enter through a vaulted front lounge room, wrapped in windows with 9' ceilings, that flows wonderfully into a generous living room, featuring an original stone fireplace. An oversized entry transitions into a formal dining room, with a bay window, that makes for great entertaining space. The two-tone cottage kitchen offers a 2023 gas range, 2025 dishwasher, breakfast bar, upgraded bay window, and slider to the yard, with real upside for those looking to further expand. Just off the kitchen, a cozy den features more vaulted ceilings and 2 new skylights, while antique details bring character to a spacious first floor full bath with walk-in shower and laundry. Upstairs, the primary bedroom spans the width of the house, with 11' ceilings, dual shallow walk-in closets outfitted with systems, a full wall of finished eave storage, and potential to add an ensuite. An upgraded full bath, 2 additional bedrooms, a generous linen closet, and attic access complete the second floor. The lower level, refinished in 2025, offers an above-grade walkout room (to the front) with 3 windows - ideal as a den or study - plus access to additional unfinished storage and a finished exterior "shed" built into the residence. Significant structure and system upgrades include new skylights (2025), a partial new roof, mostly-upgraded Andersen windows, 2015 Lennox central air and heat, 2011 vinyl cedar impression siding with Azek trim and roof, extensive sheetrock and insulation work, a 2018 hot water heater, 200-amp electrical service, floor plan changes, and more. The backyard is secret-garden style - enveloped in greenery, flowering trees and plantings, with a natural stone pathway and patio, a deck strung with bistro lighting, and an outdoor shower - while the front offers a gravel driveway, planting beds, a paver walkway and patio, and ample parking. Village of Poquott residents are afforded access to three private beaches on Port Jeff & Setauket Harbors, with exclusive mooring rights, lounge areas, and kayak/dinghy racks, a Village dock, a boat ramp, a newly updated tennis court, multiple parks and playgrounds, gardens, private security and code enforcement, and an active annual social calendar. Zoned for the Three Village School District (Setauket Elementary, Gelinas Junior High, Ward Melville High School), 18 Walnut is a three-minute drive to Port Jefferson Village's harborside downtown and ferry access to New England, and about 12 minutes to the world renowned institutions that are Stony Brook University & Hospital. Also offered for lease annually, at $5200/mo. True taxes total to $14,041, which includes Village of Poquott taxes of $1,195. Some photos have been virtually staged but all remain true to layout/structure.

18 Walnut Avenue, Setauket

$949,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1028361 MLS

Nestled on .69 acres in the coveted Strong’s Neck community, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offers a rare opportunity to create your dream home in one of the area's most sought-after waterfront neighborhoods. Featuring an in-ground pool and generous living spaces, the home is ready for your personal updates. Custom moldings, solid wood doors, and a brick fireplace are just a few of this home's amenities. Gaul Road is a unique enclave of just 40 homes, offering deeded access to Minasseroke Beach and coveted mooring rights for $250/ year. Enjoy an exceptional coastal lifestyle with a short stroll to the beach for paddleboarding, kayaking, swimming, and boating. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a special retreat, this property combines location, lifestyle, and endless potential. Taxes are being professionally grieved; the estimated reduction is $6,750.

1 Gaul Road N, Setauket

$3,900,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 909253 MLS

***Huge Price Reduction*** Magnificent Country Waterfront Estate on shy 3 acres tucked away in Strong's Neck, Setauket..1000' on Little Bay w. private dock , Privacy with rustic elegance and designed for large family with top of the line furnishings. 5 Bedrooms 6.5 baths with grand entertainment room w. large stone Frpl and soaring ceilings, beautiful custom lighting and a full bar area, The Kitchen is outfitted with Stainless appliances and large island, radiantly heated Brazilian cherry wood floors. Outdoors this Estate is designed for entertaining with an expansive decking and patios with built in BBQ station and fireplace, Pergola and In-ground pool, 4 garages 2 attached 2 detached, 6 fireplaces, private manicured level acreage with great privacy for family compound. A Rare Opportunity to combine Elegance, recreation and a Serene waterfront lifestyle.

63 Dyke Road, Setauket

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.