Shirley Homes with Includes Legal Accessory Apartment Style

Welcome to Shirley, New York—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County. This charming community offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and convenient access to vibrant urban life. With its picturesque landscapes, friendly neighborhoods, and rich local culture, Shirley is an ideal place for families, retirees, and everyone in between.

One of the standout features of homes in Shirley is the availability of properties with legal accessory apartments. These versatile spaces provide homeowners with the opportunity to generate rental income, accommodate extended family, or create a private home office. Imagine the flexibility of having a fully equipped apartment just steps away from your main living space! Whether you’re looking to invest or simply need extra room for guests, these homes offer a unique solution tailored to modern living.

Shirley boasts a variety of recreational amenities, including parks, walking trails, and nearby beaches, allowing residents to enjoy the great outdoors year-round. The community is also conveniently located near major roadways, making commuting to neighboring towns and cities a breeze. With excellent schools, shopping centers, and dining options, Shirley provides a fulfilling lifestyle for its residents.

If you’re searching for a place that combines comfort, accessibility, and the potential for financial growth through legal accessory apartments, Shirley, NY, is the perfect destination. Explore the diverse real estate options available and discover the charm of this welcoming community today!

Newest Shirley Homes with Includes Legal Accessory Apartment Style

$474,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 991406 MLS

Welcome to 66 Corbin Avenue in Shirley's West Tangier section. This is a versatile property featuring a primary two bedroom home with a full bath, living room, dining room, and an eat-in-kitchen. This house conveniently has a dedicated 1 bedroom legal accessory apartment with it's own PSEG meter. The fenced yard offers plenty of space for outdoor use. Near shopping, schools, parks, camping and transportation. Let's not forget the bridge access to the Fire Island National Seashore...

66 Corbin Avenue, Shirley

$759,000

8 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1014660 MLS

Rare flexibility awaits with this 4,680 sq ft estate-sized residence — ideal for extended family, a home-based business, or rental income. With 8 bedrooms and 5½ baths, plus a legal accessory apartment, the possibilities are exceptional. Freshly updated with new paint, new appliances, new kitchen cabinets, and an ADA-accessible bathroom. Set on a private, wooded .47-acre lot with an additional .47-acre parcel included (nearly 1 acre total, Pine Barrens–protected), this home backs directly onto Southaven County Park — no rear neighbors, yet easy access to Sunrise Highway. Highlights: This home sits on a private, wooded lot with no rear neighbors directly adjacent to Southaven County Park and Easy access to Sunrise Highway A rare combination of space, privacy, income potential, and updated finishes — don't miss it.

52 Victory Avenue, Shirley

$799,999

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1003850 MLS

New energy efficient home, 6 bedrooms with 10 ft ceilings in primary suite and a nursery off the master suite. 3.5 baths, almost a half-acre. Huge kitchen with 8 ft island and pantry with many upgrades, 10x10 deck with and overhang. 5-minute drive to Long Island Expressway and a couple miles from LIRR and the beach. Legal accessory apartment, let your tenants pay your mortgage. Many different styles and locations available.

508 Starlight Drive, Shirley

$594,600

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 971769 MLS

Cape cod with views of Great South Bay, amazing sunsets, hardwood floors, custom fenced in front and side yards, w. tall decorative grasses pines, and paved walkways outdoor shower and oasis like large back yard with decking pavers fruit trees, pool and spa hot-tub. Outdoor TV set pergolas, sheds and plenty of seating. double gated driveway, and additional off street parking. Expansive open kitchen with large butcher block island, stainless appliance and vented hood for gourmet stove. Recessed lighting chandeliers and ceiling fans, tiled sunken livingroom w. 8' sliding door cathedral beamed ceiling. Separate laundry and storage room. dining or additional living area, two bedrooms and a Moroccan and Carrara marble tiled main bathroom finish the first floor. Upstairs features 2 equal sized bedrooms either can be a master, and a marble and subway tiled bathroom, both bedrooms have large Velux roof windows that fully open offering amazing views of the great south bay. The attached garage was converted to living space and permitted as a Income producing legal accessory apartment, a 32'x14' studio features fully tiled floor a kitchen with stainless appliances, kitchen butcher block island, Slate tile bathroom, private fenced in yard with pavers and decking outdoor power and water. Close to Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge, and less than a mile to SmithPoint Beach. Major renovations include: 2018 New Fencing, New Windows & Door, Accessory apartment kitchen 2019 Ceiling fans and updated wiring & upgraded insulation 2020 Pool Hot-tub walkway Pavers and decking, driveway, & off street parking 2021 Central air, Heat pump, Velux roof windows 2025 New Sliding patio door, addition to kitchen.

79 Grandview Drive, Shirley

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.