Shirley Homes with Colonial Style

Welcome to Shirley, New York—a charming hamlet nestled in the heart of Suffolk County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Shirley offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and convenient access to the vibrant culture of Long Island. With its close proximity to the pristine beaches of the Atlantic Ocean and lush parks, residents enjoy an outdoor lifestyle that is both refreshing and invigorating.

One of the most captivating features of Shirley is its stunning array of Colonial-style homes. These timeless residences exude a classic elegance that never goes out of style. Characterized by their symmetrical facades, gabled roofs, and inviting front porches, Colonial homes in Shirley often feature spacious interiors with modern amenities while retaining their historic charm. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or looking to settle into a family-friendly neighborhood, these homes provide the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories.

Shirley is more than just a place to live; it’s a community where neighbors become friends and families thrive. The area boasts excellent schools, recreational facilities, and a variety of shopping and dining options that cater to every taste. With its rich history and a strong sense of community, Shirley is the ideal location for those seeking a harmonious lifestyle.

If you’re ready to discover your dream home in this enchanting hamlet, explore the Colonial-style properties available in Shirley. Experience the perfect blend of classic charm and modern living in a community that welcomes you with open arms.

Newest Shirley Homes with Colonial Style

$499,999

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048953 MLS

FULLY RENOVATED !! 5 BEDROOM and 2 FULL MODERN BATHS !! ALL MODERN FINISHED WITH OPEN LAYOUT ON 1st FLOOR !! ALL NEW MECHANICALS , ELECTRIC AND STAINLESSS STEEL APPLIANCES !! OVERSIZED LOT IDEAL FOR LANSCAPERS , CONTRACTORS , BOAT LOVERS TO FIT LOTS OF TRUCKS OR BOATS !! SUPER LOW TAXES !! MUST SEE FULL POTENTIAL !!

10 harrison Drive, Shirley

$459,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1032083 MLS

AUCTION/OCCUPIED. 4-bedroom, 2 bath 2,082 square foot home sitting on a 12,632 square foot lot. Property is sold “as is” with NO property disclosures, NO inspection reports, NO interior photos, NO lease in place, NO access- The seller does not represent or guarantee occupancy status. NO VIEWINGS of this property. Please DO NOT DISTURB the occupant. Buyer is responsible for obtaining possession of the property upon closing.

16 Astor Drive, Shirley

$800,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1042746 MLS

Built in 2017 this like new construction will “WOW” you with the meticulously maintained interior and the beautifully landscaped front and back yards with captivating flower beds, lush plantings, sodded front lawn and a country club outdoor setting. This 1,951 square foot colonial style home features 3 bedrooms and 2 1/2 bathrooms, and the warm welcome begins at the covered front porch with Trex decking. Enter into a soaring 2 story foyer flanked with a den and a living room with custom mantled wood burning fireplace and gleaming hardwood floors. A very large dining area has oversized picture windows giving an abundance of light plus sliding glass doors that lead to the sprawling and well-designed Fiberon deck. The incredibly spacious kitchen features an expanded breakfast bar, vast granite countertops, Whirlpool stainless steel appliances and an abundance of cherry cabinets, some with underlighting. A step-in pantry, 1/2 bath, and convenient 1st floor laundry center are adjacent. Upstairs, you will be greeted by a second story landing where a beautiful palladium window enhances the space with tons of daylight. A primary en-suite bedroom is impressive in size with room to expand and encompasses a primary bath with dual vanity, a gorgeous tiled step-in shower, and is completed with an oversized closet with custom built-in shelving. A huge unfinished room off the primary suite gives expansion opportunities for a larger bedroom, home office, nursery, or leave as is for accessible storage. The two additional bedrooms upstairs offer double closet space, and the larger of the two features an alcove. The full bath with extended vanity is spacious and pristine. Providing more space and expansion opportunities is the full unfinished basement complimented by 8-foot insulated ceilings, an outside entrance, 2 egress windows and is pre-plumbed for kitchen and bath. The highlight of the home is the amazing and masterfully designed entertainers’ dream backyard, with professionally designed grounds and superior layout creating the most extraordinary ambiance. The vast decking with room for multiple outdoor seating arrangements, sets the tone to enjoy the 18 x 33 semi in-ground pool, and the impressive "sunken" pavilion with rare architectural details and exquisite stone and paver accents. Within this structure is a full outdoor bar including the benefit of a "swim up" bar. Perfectly situated on a flat .50 acre (100 x 217 deep) the yard has PVC fencing in front and both sides. A natural backdrop offers privacy for the rear yard. A vinyl sided shed (10x14) provides storage close by. Beyond the double Belgium block driveway is a 2-car garage. Loaded with special features and upgrades, more enhancements to the home include; oversized Andersen windows, custom window treatments, crown moldings and church beveled doors throughout, 2 heating zones, indoor oil tank, forced hot air heat, separate 40G hot water heater, crown boiler w/Beckett head, 200 AMP electric, 2 zone CAC, 10 zone in-ground sprinklers, a 3 ring low line septic system, and 2017 pool filter. Each room has HDMI with CAT5 land connections. All perfectly located on a wide street with easy access to major highways, shopping, beaches, and not far from the "Gateway" to the Hamptons and the scenic North Fork. This is a must-see home, not to be missed!

406 Carnation Drive, Shirley

$675,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1044067 MLS

Welcome to 43 Harrison Drive , This spacious home offers a flexible and functional layout with generous living space throughout. Featuring well sized rooms and a versatile floor plan provide plenty of options for comfortable everyday living . Conveniently located with easy access to shopping, dining, recreation and major area roadways, this home offers generous space, character and a flexible multi-level layout inside and out. A great opportunity to make this your own!

43 harrison Drive, Shirley

$637,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1043284 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully renovated, truly turnkey single-family with home where no corners were cut! From the moment you walk through the door, you’ll appreciate the bright, inviting layout and quality updates throughout. The property features a legal accessory apartment, offering excellent flexibility for extended family, guests, or additional living arrangements. This spacious home features 4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, with 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms conveniently located on the main floor, plus 2 additional bedrooms and 1 full bathroom on the second floor. The layout offers exceptional flexibility and plenty of space for comfortable living and entertaining. Everything is new, including the roof, utilities, appliances, and water heaters. The property is also double metered, providing added convenience and flexibility. Enjoy the comfort of central air conditioning and abundant natural light throughout the home. A full basement provides an incredible amount of additional space and can be accessed from both inside the home and from the exterior. Whether you need storage, recreation space, a home gym, office, or additional living space, the possibilities are endless. Outside, you’ll find a detached garage and a beautiful lot with plenty of curb appeal and usable outdoor space. The location is conveniently situated close to shopping, stores, restaurants, transportation, and everyday conveniences. This is the home you’ve been waiting for — fully renovated, bright, spacious, versatile, and completely move-in ready. All the major work has already been done for you. Simply bring your belongings, open the door, and start enjoying your new home!

118 Floyd Road, Shirley

$750,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1041291 MLS

Welcome to 144 Dawn Dr, a warm and inviting 3-bedroom, 2 and a half bathroom home set on a generous 0.43-acre lot in Shirley, Suffolk County. Surrounded by beautiful open space, natural sunlight, and the peaceful feel of nature, this property offers a wonderful opportunity to create a home that truly feels like your own. The spacious layout was built in 2010, a brand new house that features a convenient half bathroom on the first floor, along with a wide-open concept living space that includes a dining room and eat-in kitchen—perfect for everyday living and entertaining. This property also includes a full basement with a separate exit and high ceilings. With the size and versatility of this lot, the possibilities for creating your ideal indoor and outdoor spaces are truly endless. Enjoy the convenience of being close to schools, shopping centers, major highways, medical centers, and places of worship, while being just approximately 10 minutes from Smith's Point Beach. The location offers an ideal balance of tranquility and accessibility, giving you that peaceful, spacious feeling reminiscent of having your own retreat in the Hamptons, while still being within easy reach of New York City for dining, entertainment, and a night on the town. Whether you're looking to settle in, entertain, or bring your vision to life, this property offers warmth, space, and opportunity. A true home away from home, with the potential to create your very own Hamptons-inspired retreat on Long Island.

144 Dawn Drive, Shirley

$589,888

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1036975 MLS

Welcome to 26 Probst Drive, a well-maintained Colonial tucked into the desirable Tangiers section of Shirley, offering a warm and functional layout with plenty of space to make your own. The main level features beautiful wood floors, a bright and spacious living room, a comfortable dining area, an inviting kitchen, additional living space, and a conveniently located half bathroom. Upstairs, you’ll find three well-proportioned bedrooms along with one full bathroom. The home also offers a full basement that is partially finished, providing additional flexibility for a recreation area, home office, gym, storage, or bonus space. Set on a spacious property, there is plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors, entertain, garden, or create your own backyard retreat. With its classic Colonial layout, wood floors, generous living space, and evident pride of ownership throughout, 26 Probst Drive is ready for its next chapter.

26 Probst Drive, Shirley

$657,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1033583 MLS

Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, move-in-ready Colonial, perfectly situated on a spacious half-acre. Offering the ideal blend of classic charm and modern comfort, this home is ready for its next owners to simply unpack and settle in. Step inside to a bright, welcoming layout featuring generously sized living spaces, perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The eat-in kitchen offers plenty of cabinet and counter space, flowing seamlessly into the beautiful dining and living areas. Upstairs, you'll find four well-proportioned bedrooms, including a comfortable primary suite, along with ample closet space throughout. Full basement, A/C units. Oil Heat, 200 Amp. Outside, the expansive half-acre lot provides endless possibilities — room to garden, play, entertain, or simply enjoy quiet outdoor evenings in your own private retreat with paver patio. With a one car garage, oversized driveway and great curb appeal, this property offers space, privacy, and convenience all in one package. Ideally located near local schools, shopping, parks, and easy access to major roadways like William Floyd Pkwy and the LIE, this home combines suburban tranquility with everyday convenience. Don't miss your chance to own this turnkey Colonial — schedule your private showing today!

357 Avondale Drive, Shirley

$599,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1030193 MLS

This spacious Colonial at 38 Appel Drive in Shirley offers 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a 2-car garage, and a recently sealed double-wide driveway providing plenty of parking. The main level features a large living room and formal dining room, both newly carpeted and freshly painted, along with a spacious eat-in kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and fresh paint. Upstairs, hardwood floors run throughout the second level. The primary bedroom features a recently updated private bathroom with double sinks and three closets, including a walk-in closet. Generously sized rooms and a functional layout provide plenty of space for everyday living and entertaining. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, transportation, and local beaches, this home offers a great combination of space, comfort, and convenience.

38 Appel Drive E, Shirley

$549,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1029794 MLS

Gorgeous colonial style home with contemporary flare, updated with amazing craftsmanship and magnificent attention to detail. This beauty boasts a full basement with OSE, a large and beautiful backyard and plenty of windows for the warmth and comfort of exceptional sunlight. This property has close proximity to parks, schools, transportation, shopping, eateries, and other neighborhood conveniences.

65 Westminster Drive, Shirley

$849,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 988791 MLS

Located in the desirable Woodland Estates section of Shirley, this beautifully updated 5-bedroom, 3½-bath corner property is situated on an expansive 0.8-acre lot and offers an open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, hardwood and ceramic tile flooring, recessed lighting, a wood-burning fireplace, and central air conditioning. The eat-in kitchen features designer cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and opens seamlessly to the main living areas, while a formal dining room adds to the home's functional layout. A full finished basement with an outside entrance provides a large recreation area and ample storage. Outside, enjoy a beautifully maintained backyard with a spacious deck, BBQ area, and large in-ground pool. Additional features include a fully insulated two-car garage currently being used as a game room with an electric vehicle charging hookup, a newly expanded driveway, and quality updates throughout, making this exceptional home move-in ready.

12 Deer Path, Shirley

$489,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1024282 MLS

INVESTOR SPECIAL! SOLD AS IS! LARGE COLONIAL WITH 2 CARS GARAGE FOR THE PRICE OF A SMALL RANCH. CALLING ALL HANDY BUYERS OR INVESTORS WHO ARE LOOKING FOR THEIR NEXT DEAL! ALSO PERFECT FOR ANYONE WHO IS HANDY AND LOOKING FOR A SMART BUY!

8 Windus Drive, Shirley

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.