Bay Shore Homes with Waterfront Lot features

Welcome to Bay Shore, a charming community nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This vibrant area is not only known for its picturesque waterfront vistas but also for its exceptional school district, making it an ideal place for families seeking both quality education and a serene lifestyle.

The Bay Shore School District is highly regarded for its commitment to academic excellence and holistic student development. With a diverse curriculum, dedicated educators, and a range of extracurricular activities, students are encouraged to explore their passions while achieving their academic goals. The district prides itself on fostering a supportive environment where every child can thrive, ensuring that families feel confident in their educational choices.

Now, let's talk about the allure of waterfront living in Bay Shore. Imagine waking up to the gentle sound of waves lapping at the shore and enjoying breathtaking sunsets from your own backyard. Homes with waterfront lot features in this area offer more than just a place to live; they provide a lifestyle rich in relaxation and recreation. Whether you enjoy boating, fishing, or simply soaking in the beauty of nature, you'll find that waterfront properties in Bay Shore cater to your every desire.

With a blend of top-notch education and stunning waterfront homes, Bay Shore stands out as a desirable community for those looking to create lasting memories. Come explore the possibilities that await you in this idyllic setting, where every day feels like a vacation!

Newest Bay Shore Homes with Waterfront Lot features

$5,250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1021398 MLS

We are proud to introduce Crest House, one of Cherry Grove's most extraordinary oceanfront estates. Commanding 120 feet of direct Atlantic Ocean frontage on a rare double lot spanning 0.37 acres. Built in 2012 and maintained with meticulous attention to detail, this 7,130 square foot post-and-beam residence rises three stories above the dunes and delivers an unmatched Fire Island living experience. Four bedrooms, three full baths, a powder room, soaring vaulted ceilings, three fireplaces, and a fully furnished interior make this a true turn-key retreat. The open-plan main level flows seamlessly into over 4,700 square feet of outdoor living - expansive decks, a heated pool, covered porch, and private courtyard - all framed by endless ocean views. Central air, forced air heat, and four zones of climate control ensure comfort in every season. Car-free Cherry Grove offers the rarest combination of privacy and community on the East End. Exit the ferry and enter a world where you're surrounded by nothing but the sounds of the ocean and the breeze. Properties of this caliber - this size, this position, this craftsmanship - simply do not come to market often.

55 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove

$1,500,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1011815 MLS

Welcome to Admiralty, a luxury gated community this beautifully appointed waterfront residence, where boating, private beach access, and resort-style living creates an exclusive coastal lifestyle.This beautifully appointed 2-bedroom residence showcases elegant imported flooring, soaring cathedral ceilings, and a breathtaking living room centered around a warm and inviting fireplace. The spacious gourmet kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring premium stainless-steel appliances, a stylish bar area, and an open, sophisticated layout. The primary suite offers a private spa-like bathroom and with two walk-in closets, while additional features include a washer and dryer, ample storage, a spacious garage, and attic space. Step outside to your private patio, perfect for hosting family gatherings or enjoying peaceful outdoor living. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the deep-water marina with private dockage and direct access to the Great South Bay. Situated within a meticulously maintained 158-acre waterfront community, residents enjoy an unparalleled lifestyle with 24/7 gated security, a newly renovated clubhouse, fitness center with Pilates and other wellness classes, three tennis courts, a pickleball court, private gardens, kayaking, a private beach, and a resort-style swimming pool with lifeguards. Perfectly positioned across from Fire Island’s Kismet and Ocean Beach and just a short drive to the Hamptons, this rare offering delivers the ultimate blend of luxury, recreation, and waterfront elegance. It includes snow removal, grass mowing and outside maintenance.Conveniently located near public transportation and supermarkets for easy everyday living.Just minutes from Bay Shore, offering access to shopping, dining, waterfront parks,less than two miles from ferry terminals to fire island and only one hour from NYC via LIRR. Don't miss out. https://theadmiraltyhoa.org

202 Captains Way, Bay Shore

$1,500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1002755 MLS

Amazing Oceanfront opportunity in Cherry Grove with expansive water views! Multi-level home with Living room, Kitchen, Fireplace, 2 Bedrooms and 2 Full Bathrooms on each level! Flexible layout makes it ideal to host guests or a valuable income producing property. Rent Roll provided upon request. Convenient location to Ferry, Restaurants & Shopping in Fire Island's most vibrant community! Built in 2004, this home features over 2200sf with gorgeous balcony and spacious deck. Come tour this private oasis and make it your own!

301 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove

$2,500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 988717 MLS

Featured in Architectural Digest, this extraordinary oceanfront residence on Steels Walk in Water Island, designed by acclaimed architect and designer Carl D’Aquino, is one of the most distinctive and architecturally significant properties on all of Fire Island. As co-founder of the internationally celebrated design firm D’Aquino Monaco, D’Aquino is renowned for creating homes that blend modernist architecture with warmth, craftsmanship, and a profound connection to their natural surroundings — a philosophy beautifully realized throughout this remarkable coastal retreat. Comprised of two dramatic octagonal-shaped structures seamlessly joined at the center, the home was thoughtfully conceived to embrace its breathtaking setting, where unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean, rolling dunes, and endless sky become part of everyday living. Every angle, sightline, and material was intentionally selected to create a seamless dialogue between architecture and landscape, resulting in a home that feels both visionary and deeply serene. Offering 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, the residence blends refined coastal sophistication with a tranquil, resort-like atmosphere. Expansive living spaces are carefully positioned to maximize privacy, natural light, and connection to the outdoors, creating an effortless flow between the interiors and the surrounding decks. Throughout the home, extraordinary craftsmanship and attention to detail elevate every space. The striking clapboard ceilings were meticulously installed piece by piece, creating warmth, texture, and architectural rhythm overhead — a labor-intensive design element that speaks to the level of artistry woven into the home. In the kitchen, custom cabinetry was handcrafted in Brooklyn, then carefully transported to Water Island in sections and thoughtfully assembled in place — a remarkable undertaking that reflects the bespoke nature of the residence and the uncompromising dedication to quality and design. The outdoor spaces are equally exceptional. A sprawling oceanfront deck unfolds toward the dunes and shoreline, offering multiple areas for lounging, dining, and entertaining against the ever-changing backdrop of the Atlantic. The heated pool is framed by sun-washed decking and lush landscaping, while a tranquil waterfall pond and curated gardens create moments of calm and seclusion throughout the property. Tucked above it all, the private second-floor deck off the primary suite offers sweeping ocean views and an unmatched sense of peace — ideal for quiet mornings, sunset cocktails, or stargazing beneath the open sky. Surrounded by nature and designed for complete privacy, this is more than a home — it is a rare coastal sanctuary unlike anything else on Water Island. Celebrated for its architecture, craftsmanship, setting, and atmosphere, this once-in-a-generation offering presents the opportunity to own a truly iconic stretch of Fire Island oceanfront.

1 Steels Walk, Water Island

$5,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 910335 MLS

Water Island Awaits. Two Iconic Buildings. One Majestic View. Location- Tucked between Fire Island Pines and Davis Park lies Water Island. With only 48 homes adjacent to the protected Fire Island National Seashore; Water Island creates a unique sense of remoteness and natural beauty — a true retreat for those seeking to unwind in quiet luxury. This secluded estate offers 200 feet of unobstructed Atlantic Ocean frontage; rare privacy and direct access to pristine beaches, all within an easy commute from New York City. Inspiration- A masterpiece of coastal design, this home has earned a place in the pages of several premier luxury publications. Designed by the legendary Scott Bromley of Bromley Caldari Architects with influence drawn from the craftsmanship and philosophies of George Nakashima and Hans Wegner, this expansive retreat is a study in balance — where modernist clarity meets organic warmth. The design embraces a sense of quiet luxury drawn from these iconic places: the barefoot elegance of Parrot Cay, the raw natural beauty of Big Sur, and the sculpted minimalism of Amangiri. Main House- The One-Bedroom Main House, a private and reimagined sanctuary for the Owners, sits nestled in the dunes. Inside, a warm composition of cedar and teak woods, white walls, and diffused light creates a tranquil atmosphere. The first floor serves as a serene sleeping suite, where spa-like bathing spaces are seamlessly integrated into the flow of everyday living. Above, the second floor opens fully to the landscape with expansive floor-to-ceiling windows and sliding glass doors that dissolve the boundary between indoors and out. Here, the Atlantic Ocean becomes both backdrop and focal point — a constant, calming presence, framed by architecture that gives it space to breathe. The dramatic cathedral ceiling in the main living space is punctuated by an oversized Noguchi hanging globe lighting fixture. Discover an airy chef’s kitchen where clean lines meet organic textures. Showcasing handcrafted wood cabinetry paired with caesarstone countertops – blending modern comforts like Sub-Zero, Wolf and Miele appliances. Oriented toward the coastline, the main living and dining spaces maintain a constant connection to the ocean, making it an integral part of the home’s daily life. Guest House- A meandering path through the sand joins the main house with the four-bedroom four bath guesthouse on the adjacent lot, a relaxed social hub featuring a bar, sun decks, an outdoor kitchen, and a pool — all designed to encourage barefoot living and effortless hospitality. From the moment you step inside the guest quarters you are enveloped by the integration of architectural elements – cool stainless steel, warm-toned woods, and white walls and ceilings – creating a layered, modern aesthetic. This interplay of textures brings depth and sophistication, blending functionality with high design for a space that feels both curated and comfortably livable. Details: 0 Charach & 1 West Walk Water Island, Fire Island, NY Two Structures on two adjacent lots (Total lot area - 10,000 sqft.) Connected by a Stone Path between the two Main House - 1 Bed 1.5 Bath Residence (Approx. 2,100 sqft.) 7.5’ x 5’ Custom Concrete Collaborative Panel Jacuzzi Guest House - 4 Bed 4 Full Bath Residence (Approx. 1,500 sqft.) 25’ x 9’ Custom Gunite Pool Outdoor Kitchen w/ Weber Gas Grill; Under Counter Refrigerator & Ice Maker Exterior: Clear Cedar 1X6 Clapboard Exterior Siding Mahogany and Cedar Clad Decks with Ipe hardwood trim accents Reilly double insulated, wind-borne debris rated Windows & Doors ‘Invarimate’ Contrarian Stainless Steel Roof System Interiors: Gothic European Oak Wood Floors White Washed 1X6 Clear Cedar Tongue & Groove Walls w/ Ipe hardwood trim accents Custom Designed Wood Veneer Cabinetry Caesarstone Kitchen Countertops Custom Ammonite Stone Bathroom Countertops Custom Teak Wood Sink Vessels

Charach & 1 West Walk, Water Island

$4,500,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 977357 MLS

Introducing a rare oceanfront masterpiece in the coveted enclave of Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island, ideally positioned along the border of Point O’ Woods. This custom-built home offers an exceptional level of privacy, complete with semi-private beach access via a dedicated walkway. Designed to capture the essence of coastal living, the home showcases unobstructed, panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay from nearly every vantage point. A stunning roof deck crowns the property, delivering breathtaking 360-degree water views—perfect for sunrise coffees, sunset cocktails, and stargazing under the open sky. Whether you’re relaxing beside the pool or enjoying the serenity of your own stretch of beach, the natural beauty surrounding you is unparalleled. Watch dolphins glide by, whales breach in the distance, and waves roll endlessly to shore—all from the comfort of your private retreat. Seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor living, this one-of-a-kind residence offers tranquility, exclusivity, and an elevated Fire Island lifestyle in one of its most desirable communities.

37 Traffic Avenue, Ocean Bay Park

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.